Survey: Employees Have Plenty of Suggestions

By Rebecca R. Hastings, SPHR February 29, 2012

Most North American workers make suggestions to their boss on a regular basis, according to a survey released Feb. 21, 2012, by the career and outplacement consultancy Right Management. But is the boss listening and responding to employee ideas?

When asked how often employees make suggestions to their boss at work, more than half (54 percent) of the 497 respondents surveyed by Right Management in January and February 2012, said they make more than 20 suggestions each year. Another 24 percent of respondents said they make between 10 and 20 suggestions each year.

Just 7 percent said they don’t share ideas with the boss.

Right Management found similar results when they polled employees in 2011, as SHRM Online reported.

“Despite research that indicates workers are disengaged, on the whole they want to be helpful and have their say on issues or problems that arise in the workplace” said Monika Morrow, senior vice president of career management for Right Management, in a statement.

“We find again and again that employees want to contribute,” she continued. “By making suggestions [employees] demonstrate that they’re thinking about getting the job done, and done well.”

Morrow suggested that employers take advantage of workers’ ideas, though she noted that “the boss has to judge which suggestions are worthwhile.”

Enter the Employee Suggestion System

Some organizations seek to capture and evaluate employee ideas in a systematic way by establishing a formal employee suggestion system. According to theSociety for Human Resource Management (SHRM) Employee Suggestions Poll released Nov. 8, 2010, just 39 percent of HR professionals surveyed said they had a formal system for employees to submit their suggestions and/or ideas through a mechanism such as a suggestion box, e-mail or online application.

Though a quarter of respondents said that they reviewed employee suggestions on a daily basis, 30 percent said they did so weekly and 28 percent did so monthly.

However, rather than managers, it is HR that reviews employee suggestions most often, according to the SHRM poll. Twenty-seven percent of respondents said the responsibility for deciding which suggestions will be implemented falls to HR, while 22 percent said such decisions are made by the manager in charge of the department or function affected by the suggestion. Fifteen percent of respondents said a staff committee evaluates suggestions.

In Lieu of a Formal System

Yet managers play a key role in encouraging employee suggestions, especially where no formal suggestion system exists. And the best managers “know how to unleash the potential in people,” observed Morrow. “This is a crucial management skill when talent so often is what provides a company with its competitive advantage.”

Katherine Ponds, Right Management’s regional vice president for the mid-Atlantic said managers should:

  • Set the proper tone so employees know suggestions are welcome. “This is essential for employees to have the confidence that their input is valued,” she told SHRM Online in an e-mail.

  • Communicate how they want direct reports to contribute suggestions and recommendations. Managers should “establish and articulate parameters and/or guidelines associated with the nature of submissions,” Ponds continued, such as noting particular business issues for which recommendations are especially welcome.

  • Acknowledge receipt of suggestions and consider their viability very carefully before responding to employees. Although receipt of submissions should be acknowledged, “organizational culture will determine the degree to which anonymity is maintained regarding content [of suggestions] as well as the names of those submitting recommendations,” she noted.

“Requesting written recommendations is best, as it allows the opportunity for close tracking, monitoring and follow-up by managers,” Ponds explained.

Manage Expectations

“Most employees understand that every suggestion they submit will not be adopted,” Ponds said. “However, they do want to know that their contributions are given appropriate consideration.”

Above all, employees expect managers to communicate the outcome of a suggestion.

Morrow said that employees’ willingness to participate in problem solving is a sign of a healthy workplace. At a time when many employees feel stifled in their job, it is even more important that employers show that they are listening, she said: “Make sure employees know they have a voice and a say in what happens at work. … It should be more than a gesture but a genuine effort to reach out.”

Rebecca R. Hastings, SPHR, is an online editor/manager for SHRM.

Related Articles



Hire the best HR talent or advance your own career.


SHRM's Employee Engagement Survey service focuses on more than 50 aspects of job satisfaction and engagement commonly linked to performance.

SHRM's Employee Engagement Survey service focuses on more than 50 aspects of job satisfaction and engagement commonly linked to performance.



HR Daily Newsletter

News, trends and analysis, as well as breaking news alerts, to help HR professionals do their jobs better each business day.