Not yet a Member?
HR Magazine is highlighting the next generation of HR leaders.
Is your employee handbook ready for the New Year? With SHRM’s Employee Handbook Builder get peace of mind that your handbook is up-to-date.
Attend a comprehensive, instructor-led review before you sit for your SHRM exam.
Learn to implement the complex changes and ensure compliance with the FLSA. 2-Week Virtual Seminar, Nov 29-Dec 8.
LAS VEGAS—Be careful about the wording of harassment policies, which
should be broad enough to prohibit all types of harassment without
making employers more vulnerable to claims than they would be without
the policies, recommended Jonathan Segal, an attorney with Duane Morris
Speaking at a June 30, 2015, concurrent session at the Society for
Human Resource Management 2015 Annual Conference & Exposition, Segal
noted that half of all harassment claims involve sexual harassment,
while the other half involve racial, religious and disability
Harassment claims are increasingly based on gender; these claims are
not sexual in nature, but they involve derogatory comments about women
or men. It’s imperative that policies make clear that harassment based
on gender as well as all other forms of harassment are prohibited, Segal
Include practical examples of prohibited behavior, but “focus on
inappropriateness, not illegality,” he remarked. If you say certain
behaviors are examples of sexual harassment and then they occur in your
workplace, a court may construe the circumstances to be harassment, he
Instead, say “The following behaviors are inappropriate, regardless of whether they are unlawful,” Segal recommended.
“Give specific examples to educate employees through the policy
what’s not OK,” he said. Quid pro quo harassment is, of course, always
illegal, but make that clear in your policy anyway. Also, the policy
should prohibit a supervisor politely asking for sex, as it may be
perceived as quid pro quo harassment by the recipient. “Power is
relevant,” he noted. A supervisor asking a subordinate for a date once
is fine, but more than once is not. No means no, Segal said.
Power isn’t the only factor, though. Make clear that inappropriate
behavior between employees on the same level within an organization will
not be tolerated either.
Sexual comments among two men could be perceived as harassment, as
one of the men may be uncomfortable about the conversation because of
power, sexual orientation or religion, Segal noted. And any conversation
might be overheard by other co-workers and be deemed offensive.
What about complimenting someone on what they’re wearing or saying,
“You look nice”? Whether that crosses the line may depend on how or when
it’s said, he noted. For example, compliments during an employee’s
performance review would be inappropriate.
Segal recalled one situation involving three men and one woman on a
dais. A CEO complimented the men on the job they were doing and then
turned to the woman and said, “Doesn’t she look good today?” The woman
explained to him why that was inappropriate, so he got off easy; often,
that’s not how the story plays out.
Consider including in harassment policies a prohibition on “jokes”
that make fun of sexuality, ethnicity, sexual orientation or other
characteristics. Also, prohibit any hate symbols or microaggressions,
such as saying “You don’t act gay” or “You don’t look Jewish.”
Segal recalled one workplace where a male employee called all the
female employees “sweetheart.” After he was counseled about it, he
started calling everyone “sweetheart,” Segal said, noting that wasn’t
the correction the company had in mind.
“Make clear the policy’s application to e-mail, text messages and
social media. We see a lot of harassment with social media,” Segal said.
Additionally, the harassment policy should note that it covers inappropriate behavior from employees, customers and vendors.
After-hours work-related events are another possible venue for
harassment. Segal said that, of the last 12 harassment claims he has
defended, five have involved social events. Too much alcohol and a lack
of inhibition lead to inappropriate behavior that harassment policies
Clarify, as well, that complaint procedures are available for
employees to use to raise concerns about all kinds of harassment, in
addition to discrimination and retaliation, Segal recommended. And have
multiple points of access for complaint procedures, not just the
supervisor and HR.
Managers need guidance about what to say in response to complaints.
They shouldn’t say, “That’s horrible, if true,” because they then are
calling the complainant a liar.
Segal noted that a manager once said, “You’re not the first person
who’s said that to me,” which was as good as admitting liability.
The manager should thank the individual for bringing the complaint,
assure the person that there will be no retaliation, inform him or her
that as much confidentiality as possible will be provided, and let the
individual know company procedures will be followed in handling the
complaint. “It’s OK to use a script,” Segal said.
Procedures should be available to complain about conduct by employees
and nonemployees alike, including suppliers, vendors and customers.
It’s not necessary to have an appeals procedure, Segal said, but it’s
a good idea. Give employees an e-mail address to appeal complaint
procedure determinations and tell employees all they need to say is “I
wish to appeal.”
Segal concluded by saying, “The EEOC [Equal Employment Opportunity
Commission] has said systemically harassing is a problem, and in some
places it is. I’ve tried to show areas where you can fill some of the
gaps, so the workplace you want to have is reflected in the policies you
Allen Smith, J.D., is the manager of workplace law content for SHRM. Follow him @SHRMlegaleditor.
You have successfully saved this page as a bookmark.
Please confirm that you want to proceed with deleting bookmark.
You have successfully removed bookmark.
Please log in as a SHRM member before saving bookmarks.
Your session has expired. Please log in again before saving bookmarks.
Please purchase a SHRM membership before saving bookmarks.
An error has occurred
Recommended for you
CA Resources at Your Fingertips
SHRM’s HR Vendor Directory contains over 3,200 companies