Not a Member? Get access to HR news and resources that you can trust.
Don't leave the task of calculating total cost of workforce to the finance department.
Is your employee handbook ready for the changing world of work? With SHRM’s Employee Handbook Builder get peace of mind that your handbook is up-to-date.
60+ new SHRM Seminar dates in 10 U.S. cities and virtually.
Expand your influence and learn how to become an effective leader -- Join us in Phoenix, AZ, October 2-4, 2017.
Companies should not give up on pay differentiation, even if budgets are small
As organizations finalize their salary increase budgets for 2012, Sibson Consulting's research indicates that budget levels will increase slightly over 2011 results but remain well below pre-2008 recession levels. This indicates that organizations are continuing to proceed with caution as they enter the new year.
Sibson's analysis of projected and actual salary increase budgets and salary range adjustments for executive, exempt and nonexempt classifications draws on data for 11 industry groups: banking and finance, education, health services, information services/telecommunications, insurance, manufacturing, nonprofit, retail, services, transportation and utilities.
Salary Increase Budgets
In 2011, salary increase budgets rose to 2.5 to 2.7 percent. Although this was well above 2010 actual levels, it was still below historical levels that, for the previous decade, were typically in the range of 3.5 to 4.5 percent.
For 2012, the upward trend is expected to continue, with budgets rising another 20 basis points to 2.7 to 2.9 percent. These small increases reflect business leaders’ sentiment that most companies feel comfortable enough with their financial forecasts to increase their fixed payroll costs, despite great global uncertainty triggered by European sovereign debt and, in the U.S., sluggish gross domestic product (GDP) forecasts, the political stalemate, the November 2012 elections and potential changes to the tax code.
For the first time in several years, actual salary increase budgets for 2011 were exactly as projected for executive, exempt and nonexempt employees. This reflects companies staying true to their conservative budget forecasts.
For the second consecutive year, executive increases are projected to be higher than those for other employees in 2012. This differs from 2009 and 2010, when executive salary increases were either lower or the same as those for other employee segments.
Average Increases in Salary Budgets for All Industries by Broad Job Classification
Source: Sibson Consulting.
Salary Range Increases
Salary range increases are expected to rise in 2012 but by slightly less than one-half of a percentage point to approximately 1.9 percent. Salary range adjustments in 2011 were 25 to 30 percent lower than projected. This likely reflects typical postponement of range increases, which helps moderate salary expenses for the highest-paid employees in the various pay bands.
Average Salary-Range Adjustments for All Industries by Broad Job Classification
Source: Sibson Consulting
Industry Specific Data
Key findings from Sibson’s analysis about industry specific data follow:
*Industries with the lowest actual salary increase budgets and range adjustments were banking and finance, education and nonprofit. Actual salary increases for these industries were 15 to 25 percent lower than the cross-industry average for all employee segments.
*Industries with the highest actual salary increase budgets were health services, services and utilities, with increases of up to 10 percent above the cross-industry average. Most of these premiums are reflected in the executive and exempt segments. There was little upside variation in the non-exempt workforce.
*The education and nonprofit industries continue have the lowest 2012 projected salary increases; information services and utilities have the highest.
Average Increases in Salary Budgets and Salary-Range Adjustments by Industryand Broad Job Classification
While employers are primarily concerned with the cost of talent rather than the cost of living, in January through September 2011, the U.S. Consumer Price Index rose 3 percent over the same period in 2010. This compares to a 1.8 percent increase for the same period from 2010 and 2009. Although the rate of inflation continues to be historically low, it is in line with actual 2011 salary increase budgets, which means purchasing power will remain relatively stable year over year.
Employee Prioritization and Differentiation
Organizations should continue to consider salary budgets as an investment in talent and prioritize allocations to their top performers. It is important to remember that prioritization is even more crucial in difficult times when companies need to reward their best and brightest but have a relatively small pool of money with which to work.
Companies should not give up on pay differentiation, even if budgets are small. One approach is to provide salary increases only for certain segments of employees, such as top performers, employees in critical jobs or those whose compensation is below market. A second approach is to carve out a portion of the budget and deliver that exclusively to the highest-performing employees. This ensures that a premium investment is made in those few employees who truly create value (see the SHRM Online article "How to Use 'Carve-Outs' to Truly Pay for Performance.")
Sibson research indicates that top-performing pay-for-performance companies in the U.S. are nearly twice as likely to give their best performers merit increases that are 3 percent or more than what they give their average employees. Over the past few years, when merit increase budgets were approximately 2.5 percent or less, top performers at these companies were twice as likely to see increases of 5 percent of base salary or more. This shows that while differentiation might be difficult, it is possible.
The Role of Communication
A sound communications plan is a vital component in relaying key messages to employees and ensuring their continued engagement. According to Sibson’s latest Rewards of Work Study, employees who have a good understanding of the compensation process and think that decisions are made “fairly” are substantially more satisfied with their compensation outcomes, even if the increase levels are lower. This highlights the importance of managing communications and creating transparency in the compensation system.
The implication is clear: Organizations that manage compensation in a “black box” face a headwind with regard to pay satisfaction. Conversely, those that communicate their pay philosophy and the rationale for pay decisions and place appropriate context on how they arrive at individual decisions are more likely to have employees who are satisfied with their compensation.
Organizations can satisfy their workforce better with a smaller investment if the process is communicated clearly and administered consistently. This holds true when salary budgets are high and when they are low, as many employees, especially top performers, look not only at the absolute amount of pay delivered but also at pay increases relative to peers.
Executive Compensation Implications
Projected 2012 executive salary increases are higher than corresponding increases for the exempt and nonexempt populations. This is the second year in which companies returned to the pre-recession practice of having their executive increases outpace those in other employee segments.
The Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act ("Dodd-Frank") required public companies to give shareholders their first nonbinding “say-on-pay” vote on executive pay in 2011. This up-or-down vote served as a litmus test of the organization’s executive pay strategy, designs and levels. Companies that did not do well on their first say-on-pay votes need to take steps to make their executive pay practices unassailable. This includes:
*Increasing communications with institutional shareholders.
*Enhancing program disclosures within proxy statements' compensation discussions and analyses, and phasing out controversial designs, such as lucrative perquisites, severance arrangements and change-in-control practices.
Sibson estimates that 2012 actual salary budget increases will approximate or be slightly below projected results. This projection is based on slow growth projections for the macro global economy but could be derailed by volatility generated by hot-button issues, including concerns over European debt, uncertainty regarding future U.S. tax rates, the volatility of the stock market, continued high unemployment and the upcoming U.S. elections. Organizations have shown that should any of these factors affect their growth and profitability forecast, they will not hesitate to reduce their budgets or eliminate salary increases. A lesson learned from 2009 is that the amount budgeted might not be the amount spent.
In addition, Sibson expects modest inflation in 2012, such that employees’ purchasing power will remain relatively unchanged from 2011 levels. With continued high unemployment and conservative consumer spending, any movements in the cost of labor and the cost of living are likely to be congruent.
Jason Adwin is a vice president and consultant in the New York office of Sibson Consulting. He offers specialized expertise in compensation strategy, design and performance management, creating programs targeted at all levels of the organization.
This article originally appeared in the December 2011 issue of Sibson Consulting's Perspectives, and is adapted and reposted with permission from Sibson Consulting, a division of Segal. © 2011 by The Segal Group Inc. All rights reserved.
You have successfully saved this page as a bookmark.
Please confirm that you want to proceed with deleting bookmark.
You have successfully removed bookmark.
Please log in as a SHRM member before saving bookmarks.
Your session has expired. Please log in again before saving bookmarks.
Please purchase a SHRM membership before saving bookmarks.
An error has occurred
Recommended for you
Choose from dozens of free webcasts on the most timely HR topics.
SHRM’s HR Vendor Directory contains over 3,200 companies