An employee’s viral social media post can annoy managers or co-workers, harm the reputation of the company and impair its relationships. Still, social media conduct may be protected. This article will help you identify the limits of protected social media behavior so that you can adopt a policy that prohibits misbehavior while carving out protected conduct.
A Good Policy Is Your First Line of Defense
Your social media policy should not leave employees guessing what is allowed. Clearly define prohibited conduct, such as disclosing confidential information, using social media during work time, bullying, and engaging in discriminatory, harassing, or retaliatory conduct.
A good policy also avoids liability traps, such as those described below.
The Public Sector and the First Amendment
Public-sector employers face a constitutional constraint — the First Amendment, which protects a public employee’s right to speak on matters of public concern. A public-sector employee who is terminated based on their social media speech can sue for a violation of their constitutional rights.
They can win too, if their speech was not made as part of official duties, did address a matter of public concern, and the government’s interest in efficient operations did not outweigh the employee’s speech interest.
Policy takeaways: In the public sector, your social media policy should carve out protections for statements of public concern, set clear expectations for employees who speak on behalf of the employer, and include warnings that speech interfering with workplace functioning may not be protected.
The Private Sector and Concerted Activity
Private-sector employers face their own problems constraining social media speech, including Section 7 of the National Labor Relations Act (NLRA).
On its website, the National Labor Relations Board (NLRB) instructed nonsupervisory employees that they “have the right to address work-related issues and share information about pay, benefits, and working conditions with co-workers on Facebook, YouTube, and other social media.”
That right is limited. The NLRB explained, “Such activity is not protected if you say things about your employer that are egregiously offensive or knowingly and deliberately false, or if you publicly disparage your employer’s products or services without relating your complaints to any labor controversy.”
What about social media statements that are just ordinarily offensive? You can certainly prohibit social media posts that are discriminatory, harassing, or retaliatory (that is, that would run afoul of your equal employment opportunity policies).
But disparaging comments from a nonsupervisor about an employer’s services that are related to a labor controversy (for example, complaints about pay), even when they occur online for the world to see, may have Section 7 protections.
Policy takeaways: In the private sector, provide clear context for the behaviors that are (and are not) regulated, and add a disclaimer confirming that nothing in the policy restricts Section 7 rights.
State Speech Protections
Public- and private-sector employers alike must also address a growing patchwork of states that provide protection for off-duty conduct, including on social media. Statutory protections may be limited to speech about political affiliation or may more broadly protect “off-duty conduct.”
At least some jurisdictions — including California, Colorado, Connecticut, the District of Columbia, Louisiana, New York, North Dakota, and Utah — have adopted measures protecting certain forms of employees’ off-duty political activity, lawful conduct, or expression outside the workplace.
Policy takeaway: Ensure your social media policy complies with state law, including for those you employ outside your home state.
Off-Duty Harassment
With all the guardrails of the First Amendment, Section 7 of the NLRA, and state-specific requirements, it may be tempting for an employer to take a hands-off approach to all off-duty conduct, including on social media. The 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals’ 2025 decision in Okonowsky v. Garland suggests that employers do so at their peril.
An employee worked as a psychologist in a federal prison. Her co-worker created an Instagram page where, according to the court’s opinion, he posted “overtly sexist, racist, antisemitic, homophobic, and transphobic memes.”
The psychologist found the page and was shocked by the content, including one post where her co-worker allegedly implied that he wanted to shoot the psychologist and an inmate. The psychologist reported this conduct to management and HR — she alleged that all were dismissive of her concerns.
She transferred to a different prison and filed her lawsuit alleging sexual harassment in violation of Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964.
A district court sided with the prison, concluding that all the conduct “occurred entirely outside of the workplace.” The psychologist appealed.
The 9th Circuit reversed. The appeals court held that “even if discriminatory or intimidating conduct occurs wholly offsite, it remains relevant to the extent it affects the employee’s working environment.”
Policy takeaway: Make clear that employees may not post content online that violates the company’s policies against discrimination, harassment, and retaliation.
Mark Tolman is an attorney with Parsons Behle & Latimer in Salt Lake City, Jackson, Wyo., and Idaho Falls, Idaho. Tolman is a speaker at LEAP Employment Law Conference, In Partnership With SHRM. LEAP 2027 will be held from March 31 to April 2, 2027, in Las Vegas.
Was this resource helpful?