Editor's note: Posts published on From the Workplace are written by outside contributors and do not necessarily reflect the views or opinions of SHRM.
For years, organizations developed talent through repetition. Early-career employees built capability by drafting the first version, analyzing the spreadsheet, preparing the presentation, answering routine questions, sitting in meetings, watching experienced colleagues navigate difficult conversations, and sometimes getting things wrong.
None of that looked like succession planning. But it was.
Those everyday experiences helped employees develop pattern recognition, confidence, business context, relationships, and eventually judgment. They were the training ground underneath the leadership pipeline.
Artificial intelligence (AI) is beginning to change that training ground.
AI Productivity Gain Has a Development Cost
Organizations are understandably looking for opportunities to automate repetitive work. If AI can produce the first draft, summarize the meeting, analyze the data, or answer the routine question in seconds, asking an employee to spend hours doing it manually can seem inefficient.
But HR leaders should ask a second question: What was the employee learning while doing that work? The answer matters.
If an analyst no longer performs the first analysis, where will that person develop pattern recognition?
If an early-career employee rarely creates the first draft, where will that employee learn to distinguish an average recommendation from an excellent one?
If AI increasingly provides the answer, where do employees get enough opportunities to wrestle with ambiguity before organizations expect them to exercise judgment?
The issue isn't whether we should use AI. We should. The issue is whether we are redesigning development as quickly as we are redesigning work.
Replace the Reps to Offer Growth Opportunities
Every automation decision should have a corresponding talent question:
What developmental experience are we removing, and what will replace it?
I call this “replace the reps.” If technology eliminates some of the repetition through which employees historically developed capability, organizations need to intentionally create new repetitions.
That could mean simulations, stretch assignments, rotations, shadowing, scenario-based decision-making, mentoring, cross-functional projects, or earlier exposure to customers and senior leaders.
The goal isn't preserving unnecessary work for the sake of development. It is preserving the learning that was hiding inside the work.
Succession Planning Has to Move Downstream
Many succession conversations begin too late. Organizations identify critical positions, assess potential successors, discuss readiness, and create development plans for employees already approaching leadership. But tomorrow's leadership pipeline starts much earlier.
It starts with the experiences today's early-career and midlevel employees are or aren't having. HR leaders should examine where AI is changing work across the organization and ask: Which tasks are disappearing? What capabilities did those tasks historically build? Where will employees develop those capabilities now? And are our managers prepared to create those experiences intentionally?
AI isn't eliminating the need for leaders. But it may eliminate some of the experiences that created them. That makes AI adoption more than a technology or productivity strategy. It is a succession strategy.
Alexis Byrd is a Senior Talent Leader with experience leading enterprise talent programs, workforce strategy, employee experience, early career initiatives, and human-centered AI transformation.
Was this resource helpful?