Takeaway: Defined benefit pension plans retain significant discretion in choosing the specific mortality tables and interest rate data used to calculate benefits. However, plan administrators should be careful not to abuse this flexibility by relying on outdated data in benefit calculations. Data sources should be updated as appropriate to ensure lawful benefit calculations.
The Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA) does not require pension plans to use particular mortality tables or actuarial assumptions in calculating benefits for married participants. But the data used must reasonably reflect the life expectancy of its plan participants, the 6th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ruled, reversing two district court opinions.
The issue arose when retired employees of two companies sued their respective employers and pension plans for violating ERISA. The plaintiffs, each of whom was a married participant in defined benefit employee pension plans, asserted that their plans used outdated mortality data to calculate their benefits, resulting in the systematic underpayment of benefits.
Under ERISA, defined benefit plans are required to offer unmarried participants a single life annuity (SLA), providing a defined benefit payment for the duration of their own life. Married participants must be offered a joint and survivor annuity (JSA) option, which provides that if a married participant predeceases their spouse, the spouse will continue to receive benefits for the rest of their life.
ERISA further requires that JSAs must offer married participants an accrued benefit in the form of a qualified joint and survivor annuity (QJSA), an annuity starting at the participant’s retirement and continuing through the joint lives of the participant and their spouse, followed by a survivor annuity to the participant’s spouse for the remainder of their life. The survivor annuity must be no less than 50% and no greater than 100% of the annuity paid during the participant’s lifetime. ERISA specifies that a QJSA must be the “actuarial equivalent of a single annuity for the life of the participant.”
In these two cases, both companies offered married participants JSAs that purportedly met the criteria for QJSAs.
In converting an SLA to a QJSA, the first company’s plan used a 1984 interest rate and mortality table based on data from the 1960s and 1970s. Both variables — interest rate and mortality table data — were combined to generate a “conversion factor” used to determine the benefit that would be actuarially equivalent to the SLA for a given participant. The second company’s pension plan used a similar formula also based on outdated mortality data.
The plaintiffs alleged that the use of outdated data violated ERISA because it produced higher mortality rates that assumed fewer total payments for the single life comparator SLA, resulting in a lower conversion factor for the JSAs, despite mortality rates having improved over the past 50 years.
The district courts dismissed plaintiffs’ allegations on the ground that ERISA does not require pension plans to use particular mortality tables or actuarial assumptions when calculating benefits for married participants. The participants appealed, alleging they had been denied the actuarial equivalent of an SLA as provided to unmarried participants.
The appellate court stated that ERISA Section 1055(d) specifies that a QJSA must be actuarially equivalent to the amount of SLA benefits that a participant would have received over the course of their life, from retirement to death. Noting that the critical interpretive issue is the meaning of the term “actuarial equivalent” at the time of ERISA’s enactment in 1974, the court said that at that time a mortality table was understood to be appropriate or suitable when it aligned with the life expectancy of the relevant participant population.
Actuarial literature and case law also indicate that actuarial equivalence requires mortality assumptions that reasonably reflect the lives of the applicable benefit recipients. “That means using up-to-date mortality data, not data from half a century ago,” the appeals court said.
To provide a QJSA within the meaning of ERISA, an employer’s plan “must provide a joint and survivor annuity with an equivalent value to the single life annuity the participant would otherwise receive, and that equivalence requires reasonably accurate mortality data,” the court found. This conclusion aligns with the Treasury Department’s position that Section 1055(d)’s actuarial equivalence requirement prohibits the use of unreasonably outdated mortality tables or other unreasonable actuarial assumptions, the court added.
The defendants’ argument — that ERISA does not expressly mandate that plans use reasonable actuarial assumptions and thus cannot be read to impose any substantive limits on the actuarial assumptions selected by employer plans — would render the statutory text meaningless, the court said. This interpretation would allow employers full discretion to determine the actuarial assumptions used to calculate each QJSA and, by extension, full discretion in determining the amount of benefits provided by each QJSA. Thus, employers could “select data that allows the conversion between an SLA and a QJSA to work any way the employer wants, without regard to whether the two forms of benefits have a present value that is in fact equivalent,” the court noted.
Further, defendants’ alternative argument that Section 1055(d)(1)(B) merely requires employers to disclose their actuarial assumptions in their plan documents and to adhere to those assumptions when calculating the QJSA makes little sense, the court found, because ERISA already requires employers to disclose plan terms in writing.
Finally, the court rejected the defendants’ argument regarding the ostensible difficulty of judicially determining what constitutes a reasonable set of actuarial assumptions. “Courts, particularly in the ERISA context, have frequently been, and continue to be, called upon to evaluate reasonableness, which often requires careful assessment of whether a fiduciary has acted with reasonable care in performing their obligations to protect the interests of, and manage the money owed to, plan participants and their beneficiaries,” the court said. “[T]his type of litigation is well within the wheelhouse of ERISA.”
The court acknowledged that actuarial science requires reasonable estimates, and that different actuaries may come to varying conclusions on what the exact best estimates are in each situation. “Reasonableness is a range, not a precise prescription,” the court said. However, if an employer’s assumptions “do not reasonably reflect the life expectancy of its plan participants, that employer has exceeded the scope of actuarial acceptability and failed to adhere to Section 1055(d)’s actuarial equivalence requirement.”
The decades-old mortality data used by these plans do “not reasonably accord with the life expectancy of modern-day plan participants, in contravention of basic actuarial standards,” according to the court. The alleged result is that the JSAs offered to married participants have lower present values than the SLAs they would otherwise receive, the court said.
Finding that the plaintiffs plausibly alleged they were denied a QJSA under ERISA and stated plausible claims for violation of Section 1055 and breach of fiduciary duty under ERISA, the court reversed and remanded the district courts’ judgments.
Reichert v. Kellogg Co., 6th Cir., No. 24-1442; Watt v. FedEx Corp., 6th Cir., No. 24-5945 (March 16, 2026), petition for en banc hearing denied (May 15, 2026).
Rosemarie Lally, J.D., is a freelance legal writer based in Washington, D.C.
Was this resource helpful?