As the legal and political landscape surrounding workplace inclusion shifts, employers face a difficult question: How can they maintain meaningful inclusion and diversity (I&D) initiatives without exposing their organizations to legal risk?
Employers don’t need to abandon inclusion efforts, said Kenji Yoshino, professor of constitutional law at New York University School of Law and director of its Meltzer Center for Diversity, Inclusion, and Belonging, and David Glasgow, the center’s founding executive director during the opening session at SHRM BLUEPRINT for I&D 2026, held Nov. 16 in Nashville. Instead, they should reconsider how those efforts are structured, communicated, and implemented.
Understanding the New Legal Landscape
Yoshino began by examining three forces shaping workplace inclusion: the courts, the executive branch, and organizational responses.
On the judicial front, he noted that more than 90 active federal cases currently involve inclusion and diversity (I&D) issues. The three largest categories concern targeted programs, workplace discrimination, and government programs.
Yoshino outlined three questions for employers evaluating the legality of their initiatives:
- Does the program confer preferences?
- Are those preferences based on protected characteristics?
- Do they involve tangible benefits?
Ideally, employers should be able to answer “no” to all three questions, Yoshino said, but even one negative answer may be sufficient to reduce legal exposure. These questions are particularly important as organizations reconsider programs that provide opportunities or benefits to employees based on demographic characteristics.
Meanwhile, the executive branch has considerable influence over how laws are enforced, even though it cannot independently create or change those laws. Yoshino compared this authority to putting more police officers on the road to enforce a speed limit: The underlying law remains unchanged, but increased enforcement can significantly alter the risk landscape.
That shift has become particularly apparent under the current administration, which has taken an aggressive posture toward I&D initiatives. Yoshino pointed to a statement from Harmeet Dhillon, former assistant attorney general for the Department of Justice’s Civil Rights Division: “Either DEI will end on its own, or we will kill it.”
How Employers Are Responding
The resulting uncertainty around the legality of I&D programs has produced markedly different responses among employers. According to figures Yoshino shared, more than half of organizations that are not federal contractors are increasing their inclusion efforts. By contrast, more than half of federal contractors have reduced their efforts, reflecting concerns about potentially jeopardizing government contracts.
Yet public announcements don’t necessarily reflect what is happening internally, he said. Yoshino noted that some organizations publicly distancing themselves from inclusion initiatives are continuing much of that work behind the scenes. Rather than eliminating programs entirely, employers are modifying initiatives that incorporate numerical targets or demographic eligibility restrictions, he said. Others are becoming less vocal about their inclusion efforts, seeking to maintain their commitments while minimizing public scrutiny.
Building Inclusion Programs That Last
Glasgow then turned to the path forward, emphasizing the importance of designing I&D programs that can survive changes in political leadership. The current presidential administration is temporary, he noted, and future administrations could issue executive orders taking a substantially different approach to workplace inclusion.
At the same time, the U.S. Supreme Court’s conservative majority is likely to remain in place for years, while political divisions across the country show little indication of disappearing.
Against that backdrop, Glasgow encouraged employers to consider whether their inclusion strategies are designed merely to accommodate the present political environment or if they are durable enough to withstand future changes. He outlined three approaches to reducing legal risk:
- Avoid preferences. Rather than giving certain demographic groups preferential treatment, employers should focus on removing systemic barriers and bias. The objective is to level the playing field, instead of providing advantages to particular groups.
- Broaden eligibility. Organizations can preserve the themes and objectives of existing programs while opening participation to everyone. For example, a women’s leadership conference could retain its focus on women’s advancement while allowing men and other interested employees to attend.
- Avoid exclusive tangible benefits. Employers should consider broader inclusion initiatives that improve the workplace environment for everyone, rather than delivering specific benefits to selected demographic groups.
These approaches can help organizations preserve the substance of inclusion work while reducing legal vulnerabilities associated with demographic preferences.
Shifting From Preferences to Inclusive Systems
Beyond mitigating risk, Glasgow said companies should strengthen inclusion initiatives by embedding them into everyday organizational practices, such as examining hiring, promotion, and other workplace systems for bias, adopting universal frameworks that benefit employees across demographic groups, and investing in inclusive leadership training. Upskilling to lead diverse teams effectively, recognizing potential bias, and creating environments in which employees can contribute and succeed are also worthwhile practices, he said .
Workplace inclusion should not depend on programs that distinguish between employees based on protected characteristics, the panelists said. Instead, employers can pursue meaningful inclusion by improving the systems, leadership practices, and workplace cultures that shape everyone’s opportunities. In an unstable environment defined by legal uncertainty and political change, that approach may offer organizations a more sustainable path forward.
Was this resource helpful?