Modern workplaces are all too familiar with subtle “quiet” trends, like quiet quitting, quiet thriving, and quiet firing. Now, workers are expressing discontent with employers who engage in quiet promotions at work.
Quiet promotions happen when organizations increase employees' workloads without hiking compensation, assigning a new job title, or formally providing recognition. When employees are seen as capable and reliable, they may be expected to deliver more and take on high-level tasks that don't result in career growth.
A silent promotion at work may be ideal for an organization. It allows them to continue working with high-performing employees without incurring additional overhead costs. In the short term, it can benefit employees with access to high-visibility projects and learning opportunities.
However, an increase in workload without a pay raise can affect retention. Employees can feel overworked and undervalued, leading to work-life balance conflicts and increased turnover risk. According to Gallup, compensation and work-life balance are the top two reasons employees consider another opportunity.
Thus, organizations must understand the impact of quiet promotions. Let's explore why quiet promotions should be avoided.
Read: Revenge Quitting: Is This the Beginning of the Employee Rebellion?
What is a Quiet Promotion?
When employees are expected to contribute and deliver beyond their roles and responsibilities without any official change in their salary, benefits, or designation, they are experiencing a quiet promotion.
Silent promotions at work are regrettably common, and high-performing employees are most affected.
Some signs of quiet promotions at work include:
Starting to manage a larger team.
Taking initiative on high-value projects.
Taking on the workload of a colleague who has resigned.
Contributing to decision-making.
These role modifications may come without recognition or reward or a formal announcement about the change. Employees may not immediately realize they have been quietly promoted and may be hopeful of career development and growth. They may view it as a chance to work on high-visibility projects, prove their capabilities, and progress professionally. However, employees may feel taken for granted when that fails and detach from their roles.
Effects of Quiet Promotion
Although organizations may benefit from quiet promotion for being able to fill skill gaps or vacant positions without going through the formal process of promotion, the long-term effects of such unhealthy practices can’t be ignored. Here are the key reasons why it should be avoided:
Working on high-impact and high-visibility projects is a great way for high performers to progress their careers. However, the intent and execution of promotion decisions matter. Lack of transparency and honest communication on the organization's part can cause trust loss, damage workforce dynamics, and increase turnover risk.
When employees receive quiet promotions—increased responsibilities and no proper recognition—they lose clarity of their role, and performance suffers.
Quiet promotion can reduce employees’ emotional investment in the company's success and vision.
Being overworked and burdened can affect employees' mental well-being and trigger feelings of disappointment, low morale, and disengagement.
How HR and Leaders Can Address Quiet Promotions?
To keep up with the dynamics of the industry, organizations need to stretch resources, resulting in quiet promotions or failing to update roles in time. However, HR and leaders can address this in the following ways:
Regular discussions about an employee's career trajectory, acknowledging their contributions, and planned evolution of responsibilities can help prevent misunderstandings.
Clear growth pathways and formal recognition make it easier to align employees' progress and make promotion decisions fairly, not silently.
Employees’ roles and responsibilities may be reviewed and updated formally through documentation to ensure both parties know the shifts.
Conclusion
Quiet promotions may be a quick solution for a fast-paced and resource-constrained workplace, but employees may perceive them as deceptive. They may feel undervalued, taken advantage of, and unappreciated, inhibiting an organization's retention ability.
Avoiding quiet promotions is crucial to building a high-performing workforce. Transparency, honest communication, growth opportunities, recognition, and rewards build trust with employees and help retain them.
Read: Top Strategies to Tackle Quiet Quitting 2.0
Was this resource helpful?
Validate your HR expertise
Earning your SHRM-CP credential makes you a recognized expert and leader in the HR field.
Related Content
Transform HR with mobile technology to streamline workflows, enhance communication, and boost employee engagement across distributed teams.
A new study found that talent development practitioners believe performance-based assessments are more effective at measuring employee learning outcomes than knowledge tests.
As AI makes deeper inroads into organizations, employee concerns about the technology continue to grow. Here's how HR leaders can address the fear of AI among their own staff, as well as in the wider organization.