The U.S. Department of Labor (DOL) is proposing a nationwide minimum work-search requirement for people collecting unemployment compensation, a move that would significantly tighten eligibility standards in most states, and could create new administrative and technology costs for state agencies.
Under the proposed rule, individuals claiming unemployment benefits would have to complete at least five qualifying work-search activities each week and report those activities before receiving payment. The proposal, announced by the DOL’s Employment and Training Administration, would establish a federal baseline for requirements that currently vary widely among states.
The department said the change is intended to improve the integrity and accountability of the federal-state unemployment insurance system by helping job seekers return to work more quickly and reducing improper benefit payments.
“The purpose of unemployment insurance is to provide temporary support, while people proactively search for a new job or upskill to meet the needs of employers restoring critical supply chains,” said U.S. Secretary of Labor Keith Sonderling. “This proposed rule helps job seekers find work faster and ensures efficient use of taxpayer resources, while improving the overall integrity of our unemployment system.”
For employers, the proposal could affect the composition and readiness of the available labor pool, particularly in industries and regions where hiring opportunities are limited. It also raises questions about whether more intensive work-search requirements will translate into faster reemployment or create additional frustration for unemployed workers.
The proposed rule was published Nov. 10, with a 60-day public comment period. States would generally have one year after publication of a final rule to bring their unemployment insurance laws and systems into compliance.
A New Federal Standard
Federal law requires states to maintain work-search requirements for unemployment compensation recipients, but states have broad discretion over how those requirements are structured. They determine what activities qualify, how frequently claimants must conduct searches, and other eligibility conditions.
The proposed rule would establish a uniform minimum of five qualifying activities per week, unless claimants meet specified exceptions or participate in an approved state points-based system.
Only four states currently require five work-search activities weekly, according to Michele Evermore, senior director of economic security and worker transitions at the National Employment Law Project in Washington, D.C., and a leading authority on unemployment compensation. Most states require two or three work-search activities per week.
“This is unprecedented,” Evermore said. “States set their unemployment insurance requirements through their legislatures. They have very minimal nationwide requirements under the Social Security Act. Other than that, every state does everything in their own way.”
She added that having a patchwork of state requirements is not necessarily the best way forward, but that states generally run their unemployment compensation programs, not the DOL.
On the other hand, Evermore said expanding the definition of qualifying activities is a welcome part of the proposal.
“The rule encourages an expansion of the definition of work searches,” she said. “A work search can mean different things to different people, including calling people in your network and asking about open roles.”
The proposal would require states to recognize a variety of qualifying activities, including submitting job applications, attending interviews, contacting employers, registering with placement agencies, and contacting unions about job referrals.
States could also count participation in job fairs, employment workshops, training programs, and professional certification efforts.
The DOL is also seeking public input on allowing states to adopt points-based systems. Under this approach, different activities could receive different point values based on their perceived effectiveness in helping people return to work. Claimants would still need to accumulate at least five points each week.
Potential Challenges for Workers, Employers, and States
The proposal includes exceptions for several categories of benefit recipients who could be considered to have met the work-search requirement without completing five activities each week.
These exceptions would include people enrolled in approved training programs, registered apprentices, participants in self-employment assistance or work-sharing programs, certain union workers who obtain employment through hiring halls, and individuals with firm return-to-work dates. People who have accepted jobs scheduled to begin within four weeks would qualify for an exception, for example.
However, Evermore warned that a uniform five-activity requirement could be particularly difficult for workers in rural areas, where the number of available employers and suitable openings may be limited.
“The rule will hurt people in rural areas, where work options run out pretty quick,” she said. She pointed to Florida — which required five searches — but reduced the requirement to three for rural claimants after recognizing that completing five weekly opportunities was not realistic.
The requirement could also encourage applicants to pursue positions that are not a good match for their skills or interests.
“It will compel people to apply for jobs they really don’t want nor are qualified for,” Evermore said. “Employers don’t want that.”
The broader labor-market environment could compound the challenge. The proposal comes amid what economists have characterized as a low-hire, low-fire job market, where relatively few workers are being laid off but hiring opportunities are also limited.
Long-term unemployment has also become a concern. About 27.6% of unemployed workers were out of work for more than six months as of October, compared with 20.5% three years earlier.
The proposed rule would also require substantial changes to state unemployment insurance systems, including updated intake forms, reporting processes, and technology systems to accommodate the new requirements, Evermore said. “It will likely cost states hundreds of thousands of dollars, a costly fix,” she added.
Was this resource helpful?