As AI becomes increasingly embedded in the workplace, organizations face a new challenge: ensuring employees continue to feel valued for the work they do, even when AI plays a significant role in producing the results.
For employees, that raises questions about the value of their own contributions. If AI helps complete a project, generate ideas, or streamline tasks, who deserves the recognition? And how can employers ensure that employees still feel good about the work they are doing, even if they are using the technology?
“We’ve got to be careful about how we’re recognizing use of AI and always bringing it back to the value that the employee brings,” explained Jackie Stinnett, vice president of people and great work at Salt Lake City-based software company O.C. Tanner. “Just like you can talk about collaboration and how you collaborated with people across the business, or whatever it is, AI can be a part of the reason for recognition, but not the only thing being recognized.”
SHRM recently spoke with Stinnett about how organizations should think about employee recognition in an AI-driven workplace and how keeping the human element at the center of recognition can help build employee trust.
SHRM: As AI becomes more prevalent in the workplace, how should organizations approach recognizing employees who are using these tools?
Stinnett: One thing we’re all going to have to guard against is recognizing the wrong thing. Recognition for recognition’s sake is just recognition. It’s not meaningful. So we have to make sure that we’re recognizing the right thing.
When it comes to AI, it’s really easy to recognize someone who’s jumping in and using a ton of AI and getting lots of practice and building tons of agents and has a lot of volume. What we should be doing is recognizing the value. You can build a million agents, but if they’re not solving any problems, it doesn’t matter.
We have to make sure we’re recognizing the value an employee brings in conjunction with the AI tools that they’re using, so we’re not necessarily recognizing the AI tool. We’re always recognizing the employee and the way that they used it, the problem they solved, even if it failed: “Maybe I tried this AI tool. Here’s what I learned. Here’s what I'm going to try instead.” That’s way more impactful than saying, “I’ve used AI however many hours this week.”
SHRM: Some employees may feel less valuable when they’re relying on AI to complete work. How can employers ensure those employees still feel their contributions are recognized?
Stinnett: We always have to point to: What value did the employee bring? What is the value-add with the project?
AI is just a part of that. If you are using an AI tool to reduce your workload of manual tasks, you can go on and do something that adds more value. It’s looking for the areas to recognize, not recognizing the tool itself. Employees add value as they use those tools.
SHRM: But how can organizations help employees understand that their contributions still matter?
Stinnett: Say you’re a writer. You could spend hours and hours researching, writing, putting together a story, and then publishing it. Or you could not come up with any of it and use AI to write the whole thing.
What we think people will do — and what we hope people will do — is they come up with [the idea], they begin writing it, they use tools for research, they refine it. They take research that AI has given them. They will verify it. They will decide how they want to put it together. They will use AI to refine it and publish it.
That’s work. That’s you using your talents, your skills, your expertise, and enhancing it with something that can shorten some of that time. Maybe you don’t have to use so much time researching because AI can do that for you.
It’s different work. It’s a different way of working, and it has as much, if not more, value because now you’re learning to use tools. It’s just like before we had the internet. But before we had the internet, people couldn’t imagine why we would look anything up. We had all these other resources, but then you figure out how to use that tool in a way that adds value. I think that's where the work is.
SHRM: How else is AI reshaping employee recognition?
Stinnett: AI is not meant to create the recognition experience. But what it can do is enhance the recognition experience. AI maybe can help people who are writing a message [of recognition]. The reason for the recognition is from the employee, the leader, the manager — whoever is giving the recognition. The intent is theirs. But maybe they are able to get a little help to improve their message.
Another way we are using it is for our leaders who might not always remember if there's something coming up. It can help with insights or analytics. [AI] can look at a team to see that maybe someone on the team isn’t getting recognized as much. It can nudge [leaders], about upcoming milestone events that are coming up for their people.
When you’ve got leaders who have giant teams, it’s hard to keep track of everything that’s happening. So the AI tools have really been helpful in the recognition space.
SHRM: What role does the human element play in ensuring AI-powered recognition remains meaningful?
Stinnett: We always want the human to be at the center of it. The AI is there to enhance it, definitely not to replace.
It’s not just that we recognize employees, but how we go about it. Is it personal? Is it meaningful? Did you recognize the actual value that I brought? That’s going to build trust, that’s what helps [employees] feel seen.
Was this resource helpful?