The U.S. Department of Labor (DOL) on Nov. 19 released a final rule governing how employers determine whether workers qualify as employees or independent contractors, reversing the 2024 rule and reinstating a more streamlined classification framework.
The final rule places greater emphasis on workers’ control over their work and opportunities for entrepreneurial profit or loss. It replaces the broader, unweighted analysis adopted in 2024, which the current administration argued created uncertainty for employers and discouraged independent work arrangements.
The regulation, which takes effect 60 days after publication in the Federal Register, applies to classifications under the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA), Family and Medical Leave Act (FMLA), and Migrant and Seasonal Agricultural Worker Protection Act (MSPA).
A Return to Two Core Factors
The new regulation largely restores the framework adopted in 2021, identifying two factors as particularly important in determining whether a worker is economically dependent on an employer or operating an independent business.
Those factors are:
- Nature and degree of control: Whether workers exercise meaningful control over their schedules, assignments, workloads, and ability to work for other organizations.
- Opportunity for profit or loss: Whether workers can influence their earnings through entrepreneurial initiative, business decisions, or investments, rather than simply working additional hours.
Three additional considerations remain relevant: the skill required to perform the work, the permanence of the working relationship, and whether the work is part of an integrated unit of production.
When both core factors point toward the same classification, the DOL maintains there is a substantial likelihood that the classification is correct. However, the actual working relationship remains more important than contractual descriptions alone.
The DOL also clarified that certain requirements related to legal compliance, health and safety, and quality control do not necessarily indicate employer control.
SHRM’s Recommendations Reflected in Final Rule
SHRM supported the DOL’s return to a two-core-factor framework, arguing that the approach would provide greater clarity and predictability for employers making worker classification decisions.
The organization is cited repeatedly throughout the final rule, including in discussions of economic dependence, contractual rights, workplace safety requirements, and the factors HR professionals consider most useful.
In particular, the DOL referenced SHRM research showing that HR professionals ranked the permanence of a working relationship as the second-most-useful classification factor, behind employer control. The agency retained permanence as a secondary consideration, noting its practical relevance to HR professionals.
SHRM also endorsed replacing the 2024 rule’s consideration of whether work is integral to an employer’s business with an examination of whether it forms part of an integrated unit of production.
The revised approach “more accurately captures the distinction between independent contractors and employees and provides a clearer, more administrable standard for worker classification,” SHRM stated in its comments, as quoted in the final rule.
Additionally, SHRM advocated for practical examples to help employers apply the revised framework.
“Those responsible for day-to-day implementation do not always have the capacity to parse dense legal and regulatory text,” SHRM stated, emphasizing the value of real-world examples.
The DOL incorporated additional examples addressing modern work arrangements, including digital platform workers, farm labor contractors, and truck drivers.
What Employers Should Know
Although the final rule may simplify federal classification decisions, it does not override stricter state laws, including the ABC tests used in California and other jurisdictions. Nor does it change classification requirements under federal tax law or the National Labor Relations Act.
Employers should review existing contractor relationships, particularly the degree of control exercised over workers and whether they have genuine opportunities for independent business activity.
The rule represents another significant shift in a classification standard that has changed repeatedly across presidential administrations. Maintaining documentation of actual working arrangements and monitoring applicable state requirements will remain essential to reducing misclassification risks.
Was this resource helpful?