When an employee is suddenly out on leave that results in extended time off, HR needs to understand which leave laws and policies apply, whether additional leave may need to be considered as a reasonable accommodation, and what the employee’s anticipated return to work looks like. Employers also need to know how to distribute the employee’s work while they’re out and reward the colleagues taking on additional assignments.
“Where applicable, the FMLA [Family and Medical Leave Act] may be one piece of that analysis, but it may not be the only one,” said Rachel Shaw, SHRM-SCP, president and principal consultant with Shaw HR Consulting in Newbury Park, Calif. “The ADA [Americans with Disabilities Act], state and local leave and disability laws, organizational policies, collective bargaining agreements, and even established past practices may also need to be considered.”
State law may grant time off well beyond the FMLA’s 12 weeks per 12 months, and in some states this leave is paid, unlike the FMLA’s unpaid leave. For example, most Massachusetts employees are eligible for up to 26 weeks of combined paid family and medical leave per year. Leave coordination with state laws gets complicated fast. In addition, there are federal laws such as the ADA that may require leave in addition to the FMLA or state law, as well as the Uniformed Services Employment and Reemployment Rights Act.
Don’t Lean on the Most Reliable Workers
Employee relations concerns are another layer in addition to the legal ones when someone is suddenly out on leave. If an employee unexpectedly goes out on leave, managers may be tempted to assign the extra work to their most reliable employees.
“A better approach is to distribute tasks based on skill, capacity, and developmental opportunities, rotate undesirable assignments when possible, and re-evaluate workloads periodically,” said David Gartenberg, an attorney with Littler in Denver.
While dividing tasks among existing staff is an option, he said, other options include:
- Cross-training other employees.
- Shifting work among departments.
- Reallocating resources from less critical projects.
- Hiring temporary employees or contract workers.
Temporary Workers
While hiring a temporary or contract worker is an option, there are situations where it might be less of a viable option, Gartenberg said. These might include:
- If the job requires specialized knowledge or significant training, which a temporary worker might not possess.
- Budgetary constraints.
- Operational hurdles — for instance, if the position requires security clearance.
Prioritize
It’s important to prioritize tasks, Shaw said.
“Some work can wait until the employee returns,” she said. “Some can naturally be distributed among the team. Some may need to go to a manager or someone with particular expertise. The question should not simply be, ‘Who can I give all of this work to?’ It should be, ‘What actually needs to get done while this employee is away, and what is the most reasonable way to get it done?’ ”
For shift-based and in-person work, managers can consider shift swapping, flexible scheduling, additional voluntary shifts, cross-training, temporary changes in assignments, or allowing employees greater control over when they work. For instance, fire departments and other around-the-clock operations have long used variations of shift trades and schedule flexibility because the work has to be covered regardless of who is unavailable on a particular day.
“Flexible scheduling does not have to mean remote work, and I think that distinction is important,” Shaw said. “A manufacturing employee may absolutely need to be physically present to perform the job, but there may still be flexibility around which shift they work, when a shift begins or ends, or whether qualified employees can trade shifts with one another.”
The important point is that employers should have more than one tool available, Shaw added. “If every absence results in co-workers simply being told to do more, the organization does not really have a coverage strategy. It has an overwork strategy. Employers should understand which positions can be covered internally, where flexible scheduling or shift swapping can create capacity, which jobs require cross-trained backup, and which absences will trigger the need for temporary staffing.”
What if a Replacement Is a Better Worker?
Under the FMLA, a worker is entitled to job reinstatement after their leave, except in limited circumstances, such as if they are a “key employee” and certain requirements of the employer are met.
But what if the worker’s replacement proves to be a much better employee?
In general, an employer may not replace a worker on medical leave simply because it discovers it prefers the replacement or believes another employee performs the job better, Gartenberg said.
Exceptions to this rule are rare, but they can exist, he said.
For example, if the employer discovers and can prove serious acts of misconduct during an employee’s leave, it need not reinstate the employee. But this is the exception, not the rule.
Follow Up
Importantly, managers should continue to check in with their team to make sure the work is getting done without placing too much strain on team members, said Jonathan Mook, an attorney with Ogletree Deakins in Washington, D.C.
“Employers may want to consider various types of rewards and recognition for those employees who have assumed the additional tasks,” he said. “Such rewards could include bonuses, gift certificates, and special recognition at company events. What is most important is to maintain the morale of those employees who are assuming added tasks and to make them feel their additional efforts are recognized and appreciated by the company.”
Dana Wilkie is a freelance journalist based in Ormond Beach, Fla.
Was this resource helpful?