Takeaway: The Rehabilitation Act provides significant legal protections to federal employees with disabilities. However, it only requires federal agencies to provide a reasonable accommodation, not the employee’s preferred accommodation.
An employee who claimed her accommodations were not fully effective could not show any violation of the Rehabilitation Act.
The U.S. State Department hired the plaintiff as a fellow for the American Association for the Advancement of Science (AAAS) in February 2016. Because the plaintiff had a visual impairment, the State Department’s Disability and Reasonable Accommodation Division provided her with several accommodations. The accommodations included software to help the plaintiff read her computer screen, and noise-cancelling headphones to help her hear the software read to her.
The plaintiff claimed that her screen-reading software did not work well enough and the State Department failed to promptly provide her with people to read aloud from her computer screen. The State Department also placed her in an office that was not sufficiently quiet, and the noise interfered with the use of her screen reading software. In addition, she claimed that her supervisor berated her and screamed at her.
In June 2016, the plaintiff received a letter from the AAAS offering to renew her fellowship for another year beginning the following February to sign and return by June 10. When the plaintiff proposed delaying the return of the renewal paperwork until June 16, the AAAS agreed. The plaintiff proposed several changes to the renewal paperwork but did not return it.
The State Department and the AAAS eventually decided to rescind plaintiff’s renewal offer. The AAAS sent the plaintiff a letter on July 19 stating that the deadline to submit renewal paperwork had passed more than a month before and that discussions with the plaintiff showed that her interests were not aligned to result in a mutually beneficial renewal year.
In August 2016, halfway through her fellowship year, the plaintiff filed a formal complaint with the State Department’s Office of Civil Rights. In it, she alleged discrimination based on her disability and reprisal. Her evidence included an email documenting demeaning comments by her supervisor, the denial of professional opportunities, and the rescission of her renewal offer.
Over a month later, the plaintiff met with colleagues to discuss the departure of the leader of an ocean acidification portfolio. When asked directly, the plaintiff did not recommend herself to take the departing leader’s place. Nor did anyone else recommend her. The State Department later made a different fellow leader.
On Sept. 26, the plaintiff emailed the director of the Disability and Reasonable Accommodation Division to compliment their work. The plaintiff said they had accommodated her completely.
The plaintiff then made several accommodation requests. In October, she renewed her request from earlier in the spring for an office space away from loud office equipment and talkative co-workers. In November, she requested help to have someone read what was being displayed on our computer because her adaptive software was not working. She also reported issues with her computer shutting down, not displaying the login screen correctly, and making a grinding sound.
Five years later, the plaintiff sued the State Department under the Rehabilitation Act. She claimed that the State Department failed to accommodate her disability and discriminated and retaliated against her for requesting accommodations and filing her August 2016 administrative complaint. The State Department filed a motion for summary judgment, and the district court granted that motion. The plaintiff appealed to the U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia.
On appeal, the D.C. Circuit found that the State Department fulfilled its responsibilities to reasonably accommodate the plaintiff. The State Department moved the plaintiff to a quieter office, supplied her with noise-cancelling headphones, provided her with people who could read screen text to her, and tried to fix the issues she encountered with her desktop. The plaintiff admitted that the State Department resolved her adaptive software issues in November 2016. The court noted that the disability law only requires reasonable, not perfect, accommodations. Thus, the plaintiff could not show that the State Department failed to accommodate her.
Her discrimination and retaliation claims over failing to receive ocean acidification leadership duties and not getting her fellowship renewed also failed. Both alleged adverse actions stemmed from the plaintiff’s lack of initiative in seeking the leadership duties and expressing interest in the renewal of her fellowship, the court concluded.
The D.C. Circuit upheld the district court’s dismissal of the claims.
Qashu v. Rubio, D.C. Cir., No. 24-5201 (April 10, 2026).
Jeffrey Rhodes is an attorney with McInroy, Rigby & Rhodes LLP in Arlington, Va.
Was this resource helpful?