The Trump administration is proposing sweeping changes to the employment-based immigration system which could significantly increase the time, cost, and compliance responsibilities employers face when sponsoring foreign workers for permanent residence.
The Department of Labor (DOL) issued a proposed a rule on Nov. 17 that would overhaul the Permanent Labor Certification Program, commonly known as PERM. The process requires employers to demonstrate that qualified U.S. workers are not available for a position before sponsoring a foreign national for an employment-based green card under the EB-2 or EB-3 categories.
The proposal represents the first comprehensive revision of PERM regulations in over 20 years. Its most consequential provisions include a two-year lookback period for certain layoffs, expanded recruitment requirements, more extensive documentation obligations, and the elimination of Schedule A, which currently allows employers sponsoring nurses, physical therapists and certain other workers to bypass the standard labor market test.
“American Workers … deserve the first and best job opportunities. Existing regulations have instead allowed companies to sponsor foreign workers without fully considering American workers first,” said U.S. Secretary of Labor Keith Sonderling. “This proposed rule change will ensure American workers are first in line for high-skilled, high-paying job opportunities over foreign labor.”
The proposal comes amid heightened federal scrutiny of employment-based immigration programs. In October, Vice President JD Vance announced that Microsoft and several other companies would be suspended from PERM over alleged fraud. In addition, the U.S. Department of Justice and the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission recently secured settlements with Instacart and OpenAI over alleged discrimination against U.S. workers during PERM recruitment.
The rule is not final and would not immediately change employer sponsorship requirements. DOL is seeking public comments for 60 days following publication, after which it must consider the feedback before issuing a final regulation. Experts say that the changes could fundamentally alter how immigration sponsorship intersects with recruiting, workforce planning, and restructuring decisions.
A More Extensive Recruitment Process
The proposed rule would fundamentally restructure the recruitment process employers must complete before filing a PERM application.
Under current regulations, employers generally must place a 30-day job order with a state workforce agency, run two Sunday newspaper advertisements, and complete three additional recruitment steps for professional positions. The proposed rule would replace the print-based requirements with online recruitment channels and require employers to use methods that mirror their customary practices for filling comparable positions that do not involve immigration sponsorship.
Employers would generally need to advertise through their websites, at least one external job search website, and social media platforms when those channels are customarily used for comparable positions. They could also use job fairs, campus recruiting events, or educational institution placement offices, as applicable. Job ads would need to disclose the offered wage or wage range and additional job details.
Most importantly, advertisements would have to remain active for at least 90 calendar days, or longer if the employer customarily advertises comparable positions for a longer period. That minimum requirement is just 30 days now.
Jihan Merlin, an immigration attorney and head of immigration strategy at Alma, based in Palo Alto, Calif., said eliminating newspaper advertising could provide some financial relief for employers.
“It’s historically been the most expensive part of the PERM process, because there aren’t any filing fees associated with PERM. That could be a cost savings,” she said.
She also sees merit in modernizing recruitment practices to reflect how people actually search for jobs.
“Nobody thinks U.S. applicants are combing through newspaper advertisements or listening to the radio for a job opportunity,” she said. “The types of things that have been permissible are surprising, and I do think that some companies have taken advantage of those provisions to limit the number of applicants who apply.”
However, she cautioned that the expanded online recruitment requirements could create significant operational challenges, particularly for employers that already receive large volumes of applications.
“There is trepidation around the requirements to post jobs on the company website and social media,” Merlin said. “In certain industries and for some companies this requirement will effectively shut down their PERM recruitment programs.”
Layoffs Could Disrupt Sponsorship for Two Years
The proposal’s most consequential workforce planning implications may stem from its treatment of layoffs.
Currently, employers that have laid off U.S. workers in the same or a related occupation and geographic area within six months before filing a PERM application must notify potentially qualified affected workers about the position and consider those who apply.
The proposed rule would extend that lookback period to two years and categorically prohibit approval of a PERM application when qualifying layoffs have occurred during that period, explained Amy Peck, an immigration attorney in the Omaha, Neb., office of Jackson Lewis.
The proposal would also introduce continuing obligations when layoffs occur after a PERM application has been filed and through approval of the associated Form I-140 petition, she said.
Under the proposed requirements, employers would need to notify DOL and, when applicable, U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services within five business days of covered layoffs. They would also have to notify affected workers about the sponsored position, consider them for the opportunity, and document the outcome.
The expanded restrictions would require employers to pay much closer attention to workforce changes throughout the sponsorship process, Peck said.
The changes would be particularly disruptive for employers with recurring workforce reductions and for their H-1B employees approaching max-out dates, Merlin warned. Some companies might decide to withdraw pending PERM applications rather than undertake the additional work required to notify and reconsider laid-off employees, she added.
“It’s a huge burden on employers,” she said.
Schedule A Elimination Would Affect Healthcare Employers
Another major provision would eliminate Schedule A, the category of occupations that the federal government has determined face a shortage of qualified U.S. workers.
Schedule A currently includes professional nurses and physical therapists, as well as certain individuals with exceptional ability in the sciences or arts. Employers sponsoring workers in these occupations can bypass the standard PERM labor certification process.
DOL said in the proposed rule that it can no longer confirm that nationwide shortages exist to justify maintaining the exemptions and argued that federal immigration law does not authorize the agency to exempt occupations from the labor market test.
If the proposed rule is adopted, employers would generally need to complete the full recruitment and labor certification process for these workers. The change would have substantial implications for healthcare organizations already struggling to fill clinical positions. DOL estimates an average of 23,835 Schedule A petitions were filed annually between fiscal years 2023 and 2025.
Eliminating the exemption would remove an important pathway for employers in healthcare and other specialized industries, said Dimo Michailov, an attorney with Capitol Immigration Law Group in Washington, D.C.
More Documentation, Longer Timelines
Beyond recruitment changes and layoff restrictions, the proposal would fundamentally change how employers submit PERM applications.
Currently, PERM operates largely as an attestation-and-audit system. Employers attest they have complied with recruitment requirements and found no qualified, available U.S. workers, but generally do not submit supporting documentation with the initial application unless DOL selects the case for an audit, which is uncommon.
Under the proposal, employers would have to submit the prevailing wage determination, Notice of Filing, recruitment documentation, a detailed recruitment report and the resumes or applications of all U.S. workers who applied.
“The proposed PERM rule will significantly increase the administrative burden and timelines for employers sponsoring foreign talent,” Michailov said. “Shifting to a front-loaded evidentiary model, companies must now submit comprehensive recruitment proofs, detailed reports, and applicant resumes at the exact time of filing.”
He estimated the pre-filing process could extend to at least nine or 10 months, accounting for prevailing wage determinations that can take five months, mandatory 90-day recruitment campaigns, and the required waiting period before filing.
What Employers Should Do Now
Although the proposal could still change substantially following public comments, employers should begin evaluating how its provisions could affect their operations.
“Employers should assess how longer recruitment periods, layoff history, and coordination among recruiting, HR, and immigration teams could affect sponsorship plans,” Peck said.
She added that the rule is likely to generate considerable interest from employers and other stakeholders, potentially producing a high volume of public comments. DOL must meaningfully consider significant issues raised during the comment period, meaning the final regulation could differ from the current proposal.
Employers should use the public comment period to explain the operational consequences of the proposed changes, Merlin said.
“My recommendation for employers is to submit comments,” she said. “These changes are still proposed, but employers should consider their impact on sponsorship timelines, workforce planning, and compliance. Describe what the impact of the rule will be to your business.”
Was this resource helpful?