Navigating the U.S. visa landscape can be complex for both organizations seeking global talent and workers aspiring to learn and gain experience in the U.S. H-1B and J-1 visas are both popular options, each offering unique opportunities, requirements, and considerations. Learning about visa options is essential for employers seeking to build a globally competitive workforce, and for professionals planning to advance their careers through work or training in the U.S.
The H-1B visa has long been the primary route for hiring highly skilled foreign workers, especially in the technology sector. However, with intense competition, annual caps, and recent regulatory changes, securing an H-1B has become increasingly difficult and costly. These changes have led many organizations to explore other visa options.
The J-1 Exchange Visitor Program is emerging as a strategic pathway for international workers to gain access to training and experience in the U.S. It is not a work visa but a temporary nonimmigrant visa with a strong cultural exchange component. It is not designed to fill an existing position, but it can still have real benefits for both the visa holder and the organization with which they’re training.
By understanding the differences between the H-1B and J-1 visa programs, business leaders and HR professionals can make more informed decisions to secure the skilled individuals needed to drive their organizations forward.
What is an H-1B Visa?
The H-1B visa is a temporary, nonimmigrant visa that allows U.S. employers to hire foreign professionals in "specialty occupations." These are roles that require the theoretical and practical application of a highly specialized body of knowledge. It is a dual-intent visa, allowing participants to apply for permanent resident status during their employment.
H-1B Visa Requirements
To qualify for an H-1B visa, both the position and the potential employee must meet strict criteria set by U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS).
For the Position: The job must typically require a bachelor's degree or higher in a specific field. This can be demonstrated if a degree is the normal minimum entry requirement for the position, is common for similar roles in the industry, or if the duties are so specialized and complex that they require a degree.
For the Applicant: The foreign worker must hold a U.S. bachelor's degree (or a foreign equivalent) required by the specialty occupation. Alternatively, they can hold an unrestricted state license, registration, or certification in the specialty occupation, or have work experience equivalent to a bachelor's degree.
H-1B Limitations and Duration
The H-1B program is subject to an annual numerical cap, which makes it highly competitive. Currently, the cap is set at 85,000 visas per fiscal year, with 20,000 of those reserved for applicants holding a U.S. master's degree or higher. Demand far exceeds supply, necessitating a lottery system to select eligible petitions.
An H-1B visa is initially granted for up to three years and can be extended for a total of six years. In certain circumstances, such as when a green card application is in process, further extensions beyond the six-year limit may be possible.
How Much Does an H-1B Visa Cost?
The cost of an H-1B visa can be substantial for employers. While the initial lottery registration fee is low, subsequent legal and filing fees can amount to as much $100,000 if the petition is selected.
Policy changes, such as the additional $100,000 fee for new petitions recently announced by President Donald Trump, signal a trend toward significantly higher costs, particularly impacting small and mid-sized businesses. These higher costs could make the H-1B visa prohibitively expensive for many companies.
Why the H-1B Visa Is Becoming More Challenging
Recent developments have made the H-1B program more challenging for employers. The U.S. Department of Homeland Security (DHS) has proposed changes to the lottery, moving from a random selection to a weighted system that prioritizes higher-paid workers. While this aims to attract top-tier talent, it could disadvantage smaller companies, startups, and nonprofits that cannot compete with the salaries offered by large tech corporations.
Furthermore, proposals for increased fees and stricter oversight have created an environment of uncertainty. These shifts underscore the need for businesses to diversify their talent acquisition strategies and consider reliable alternatives.
What is a J-1 Visa?
The J-1 visa, part of the BridgeUSA program, is designed for individuals participating in work-and study-based exchange visitor programs approved by the U.S. Department of State. Its primary purpose is to promote cultural and educational exchange. Participants come to the U.S. to teach, study, conduct research, receive training, or demonstrate special skills. A J-1 visa holder is only in the U.S. for the duration of the proposed activity, and does not intend to immigrate to the U.S.
J-1 Visa Requirements
The J-1 visa requirements are specific to the program category under which the applicant is applying. Unlike the H-1B, the J-1 visa is not limited to "specialty occupations," requiring a bachelor's degree, which offers more flexibility. The focus is on providing structured training and cultural exchange.
SHRM, as a designated sponsor, can issue sponsorships for several categories, such as:
Intern: For current university students or recent graduates (within 12 months) seeking an internship in their field of study.
Trainee: For professionals with a degree and one year of work experience, or five years of work experience in their occupational field.
Specialist: For foreign nationals who are experts in a field of specialized knowledge, coming to the U.S. to observe, consult, or demonstrate their skills.
Research Scholar: For professionals whose primary objective is to conduct research, observe, or consult on projects at research institutions or corporate research centers.
How J-1 Visas Are Used
Can you work on a J-1 visa? Yes, but only under the terms of the specific exchange program. The J-1 program is widely used across various industries to build talent pipelines and facilitate knowledge sharing. For example, the hospitality and tourism industry frequently uses the J-1 Intern and Trainee program to develop future managers.
The recent Early Career STEM Research Initiative by the Department of State also aims to increase the use of J-1 visas for professionals in science, technology, engineering, and mathematics.
In the corporate world, businesses use the J-1 program for rotational leadership development tracks, research collaborations, and bringing in specialists from global subsidiaries for specific projects. Workers on a J-1 visa can be particularly beneficial for global organizations. A company could train an international manager in the U.S. and then continue to employ that manager after they’ve returned to their home country.
How Long Can a J-1 Visa Holder Stay in the US?
The duration of a J-1 visa depends on the program category. A Short-Term Scholar can stay for up to six months, while Interns and Specialists can stay for up to 12 months. Trainees can participate in programs for up to 18 months, and Research Scholars can stay for up to five years. This flexibility allows employers to tailor the program length to their specific business needs.
How Much Does a J-1 Visa Cost?
The cost of a J-1 visa is generally lower and more predictable than the H-1B. It involves fees for the sponsor organization (like SHRM), a SEVIS fee paid to the government, and visa application fees. For example, SHRM offers expedited processing for new clients for $2,110 per application plus a $200 Student and Exchange Visitor Information System (SEVIS) fee, making it an affordable, accessible option for applicants working in a wider array of industries.
The J-1 Visa as a Strategic Alternative
With the H-1B visa becoming increasingly difficult and expensive to obtain, the J-1 program presents another option. Here are some scenarios where a J-1 visa may be the ideal choice:
Building a Talent Pipeline: Use the J-1 Intern and Trainee programs to evaluate high-potential individuals before making a long-term hiring commitment to a worker once they return to their home country. This is an effective way to build a pipeline of future leaders for a global organization.
Short-Term Projects and Specialized Skills: The J-1 Specialist program is perfect for bringing in experts for projects lasting up to 12 months, without the uncertainty of the H-1B lottery.
Research and Development: The Research Scholar program allows organizations to host international experts for long-term research and development projects, fostering innovation and global collaboration.
Can a J-1 Visa be Converted to an H-1B?
A common question is whether a J-1 visa can be converted to an H-1B. While there is no path to directly convert a J-1 visa into any other kind of visa, a J-1 visa holder can later apply for an H-1B visa through the standard process. However, some J-1 participants are subject to a two-year home-country physical presence requirement, meaning they must return to their home country for two years before they can apply for certain other visa types, including the H-1B.
J-1 Visa vs. H-1B Visa: A Direct Comparison
Feature
|
H-1B Visa
|
J-1 Visa
|
Primary Purpose
|
To fill specialty occupation roles with foreign professionals.
|
To promote cultural and educational exchange through structured programs.
|
Eligibility
|
Requires a bachelor's degree or equivalent in a specific field.
|
Varies by program; can be based on education, work experience, or specialized skills.
|
Annual Cap
|
85,000 per year (highly competitive lottery).
|
No annual cap.
|
Employer Sponsor
|
The employer petitions directly to USCIS.
|
A designated sponsor (like SHRM) issues eligibility forms.
|
Duration of Stay
|
Up to 6 years, with potential for longer extensions.
|
Varies by program, from 6 months (Short-Term Scholar) to 5 years (Research Scholar).
|
Dependents
|
Spouses and children may accompany an H-1B visa holder on an H-4 visa and may be eligible for work authorization in limited cases.
|
Spouses and children may accompany a J-1 visa holder on a J-2 visa are eligible to apply for work authorization.
|
Cost
|
Total costs for filing and processing can exceed $200,000 per application.
|
SHRM will sponsor an application for $2,110 plus a $220 SEVIS fee. Applicants will also need to pay a filing fee of $185.
|
Path to Green Card
|
"Dual intent" visa, meaning holders can pursue permanent residency.
|
"Non-immigrant intent" visa, meaning holders cannot pursue permanent residency.
|
Is a J-1 Visa Right for You?
For employers, a J-1 visa program is an excellent choice if your goal is to provide structured training, facilitate cultural exchange, or bring in specialists for a defined period. It offers a more predictable, cost-effective, and flexible alternative to the H-1B.
For potential applicants, a J-1 visa provides an invaluable opportunity to gain U.S. work experience, develop professional skills, and immerse yourself in a new culture. If you are a current student, a recent graduate, or a professional with specialized expertise, the J-1 program could be your bridge to a career-defining experience in the United States.
How SHRM Can Help with J-1 Visas
As a U.S. Department of State-designated sponsor for over seven years, SHRM helps organizations navigate the complexities of the J-1 program. SHRM does not directly partner with businesses to place interns, trainees, specialists, and research scholars. SHRM does have referral relationships with international placement agencies that can help match applicants with organizations.
The process is smooth, efficient, and repeatable. SHRM has issued thousands of sponsorships across more than 30 countries. For an additional fee, SHRM offers expedited application processing within 5 days of receiving all application materials.
Your Next Strategic Move
While the H-1B visa remains a crucial tool for hiring long-term specialty workers, the J-1 program provides a flexible and powerful alternative for building talent pipelines, fostering innovation, and gaining a competitive edge. By understanding the unique benefits of the J-1 visa, you can unlock new opportunities to bring the world's best talent to your organization.
Get a free consultation with a SHRM representative, and find out if a J-1 Visa is the right solution for you.
An organization run by AI is not a futuristic concept. Such technology is already a part of many workplaces and will continue to shape the labor market and HR. Here's how employers and employees can successfully manage generative AI and other AI-powered systems.
Related Content
Learn how Marsh McLennan successfully boosts staff well-being with digital tools, improving productivity and work satisfaction for more than 20,000 employees.
The proliferation of artificial intelligence in the workplace, and the ensuing expected increase in productivity and efficiency, could help usher in the four-day workweek, some experts predict.
As artificial intelligence technology continues to develop, the demand for workers with the ability to work alongside and manage AI systems will increase. This means that workers who are not able to adapt and learn these new skills will be left behind in the job market.