Building a high-performance culture requires more than setting ambitious goals and holding employees accountable. Leaders also must create an environment where people feel valued, safe, and empowered to speak up. JP Pawliw, a best-selling author and expert on leadership and organizational performance, discussed with SHRM how leaders can balance accountability, trust, and employee experience to drive results.
SHRM: What does a high-performance culture look like in practice, and how can leaders tell when they’ve struck the right balance between results and employee experience?
Pawliw: It’s easy to get out of balance. Some leaders over-index on employee experience, assuming that alone drives results. Others focus so hard on results they ignore the people delivering them. Both extremes are misguided.
Organizations exist to deliver what their stakeholders need, from shareholders to employees, customers, and community, depending on how broadly the organization defines that. But you only get results when you understand what drives them: people. And people only perform at their best when their emotional needs — feeling valued, included, safe, respected, autonomous, and competent — are met.
Why does that matter so much? Because the biggest differentiator on high-performing teams is that people take interpersonal risks: saying or doing something important even when it might cost them their feeling of belonging. When emotional needs are met, people are far more likely to take risks under pressure rather than stay silent.
There are two signs that leaders have struck the right balance:
First, employees close the “last 8%” gap. In a study of 34,000 people, we found a 7.56% gap — rounded to 8% — between the risks people felt they should take and the risks they actually took. They held back the hard truth, the inconvenient challenge, the thing that needed to be said. Leaders know they’ve gotten it right when people raise hard issues before results slip, not after.
Second, when pressure doesn’t break trust. A high-performance culture isn’t the absence of pressure, nor is it leaders applying more of it. It’s the ability to stay connected, maintain trust, and meet people’s emotional needs, even under pressure.
The fix isn’t dialing back ambition. True high performers and high-performance environments thrive on a big challenge, a big ambition. The balance comes from a different place: leaders need to become students of human behavior. That means understanding what actually drives and motivates people beyond salary, what gets them to give discretionary effort and become emotionally committed to the organization’s goals.
Here’s the counterintuitive part: a strict focus on results actually undermines results. We’ve seen this firsthand in sports. One of the biggest mistakes athletes and coaches make heading into big games is carrying the wrong goal onto the field, which is winning. Winning is a byproduct of doing everything right, not something you chase directly. Point an athlete at winning and you point them at something they can’t fully control, which makes them uptight and pulls their focus from what actually matters. It plants fear of mistakes. Once that pressure sets in — this moment is critical, this game is critical — one of two things happens: people try too hard and force everything, or they tighten up and play it safe.
So instead of focusing on outcomes, leaders should focus on what we call integrity of inputs. That’s everything described above: creating the conditions where people take interpersonal risk because their emotional needs are met and they feel genuinely connected. Get that right, and discretionary effort and emotional commitment follow — the same forces that drive innovation and results. None of that can be commanded or bought. It can only be earned.
SHRM: What are the early warning signs that an organization’s culture has become misaligned with its business strategy?
Pawliw: Watch for avoidance, which can manifest in some very subtle ways. One of the most obvious areas where we see this occur is in meetings. Meetings are, of course, universal to all organizations and critical to keeping up momentum and progress on delivering results, yet some use these far less effectively than others. And avoidance is a big reason for the difference.
If in meetings real disagreement never surfaces, feedback only flows top-down, or decisions are made in hallways after the meeting rather than in the meeting, then you do not have the culture that can execute your strategy. Why? Because people do not say what needs to be said, tough decisions do not get made, and things like naming inconvenient truths never occur. People are more worried about looking good than doing good. So, interpersonal risk becomes a huge strategic liability.
SHRM: How do leaders create genuine ownership among employees?
Pawliw: Leaders create ownership by helping people see the big picture and where they fit in it, and by rewarding attempts at courage, not just outcomes.
Ownership can’t be assigned, though we often mistake it for something that can be. Putting someone’s name on a deliverable isn’t ownership. Real ownership is built through repeated moments — someone takes a risk, speaks up, challenges an idea, admits a mistake — and it goes well. Their courage gets acknowledged, maybe even rewarded. That act of stepping into the hard thing is what shapes a person’s internal reputation, their opinion of themselves. And that’s what fuels the next cycle: more smart risk-taking leads to more ownership, which makes the next risk easier to take.
SHRM: What role does psychological safety play in a high-performance culture?
Pawliw: Psychological safety isn’t the goal; it’s the precondition. It’s what lowers the perceived stakes when someone feels they need to take an interpersonal risk, like speaking up or disagreeing with a teammate.
That’s because the core fear driving people’s hesitation isn’t the disagreement itself — it’s the worry that speaking up could cost them their place in the tribe if things go sideways. A real sense of connection and belonging is what protects against that fear. And that protection is exactly what makes it possible to close the last 8% gap described earlier.
SHRM: What is the biggest misconception executives have about building a high-performance culture?
Pawliw: The biggest misconception is that high performance and hard conversations are in tension; that you have to choose between pushing results and protecting relationships. You don’t.
In fact, the relationship runs the other way: doing one well feeds the other. Hard conversations and hard decisions, handled well, deepen the connection that drives high performance. And that connection, in turn, makes the next hard conversation easier to have. It’s bidirectional.
The organizations that outperform are the ones that have closed the gap between the risk people know they should take and the risk they actually take. That gap closes when people have both drivers of interpersonal risk-taking in place: the skill to step in and do the hard thing, and an environment where their emotional needs are met enough to actually use that skill. Each is roughly half the equation. In our lexicon, the best organizations operate with high care for their people and high accountability from their people simultaneously. That’s the balance any leader should be striving for.
Was this resource helpful?