Effective witness preparation for any formal proceeding is crucial and can significantly affect a jury’s perception of a case and the employer. This is particularly true for an HR witness. HR typically testifies more than an ordinary fact witness. HR professionals do not just represent themselves; they often are the face of the company for the jury. This means that the margin for error is small.
Jurors expect HR to fully understand company policies and ensure employees are treated fairly. At the same time, jurors bring their own workplace experiences into the courtroom, which may shape how they perceive HR and create some skepticism from the outset. For that reason, trial preparation should go beyond preparing HR to answer questions. The witness should also be ready to clearly explain what happened, why the company acted as it did, and how HR’s role fit into that process.
HR Will Likely Be Called as an Adverse Witness
In a trial, the plaintiff always presents their evidence first, including their witnesses. A typical ploy is that the plaintiff’s attorney will call key company witnesses adversely, and there is a significant chance that will include HR. For an adverse witness, the plaintiff’s lawyer is allowed to “lead” the witness – that is, ask leading questions designed to elicit “yes” or “no” answers without explanation.
An example: “Isn’t it true that based on her time records, the plaintiff was not late on two of the five days that you counted her as tardy?” Or: “Isn’t it true that your supervisor violated company policy when he failed to report the plaintiff’s sexual harassment complaint?”
It is important that the HR witness be prepared to respond directly to leading questions, and not argue with the plaintiff’s lawyer. The company’s lawyer will assert appropriate objections, and then on cross-examination, can ask questions that will allow the witness the opportunity to explain as necessary.
Know Your Policies and Be Ready to Explain How They Work
HR needs to have full command of applicable company policies. The witness needs to explain how policies operate in practice and how they apply to the employee or situation involved in the case. If the policy gave management discretion, HR should be prepared to explain why discretion is necessary and how that discretion was exercised and why.
Just as importantly, those explanations should be given in plain language that a jury can easily understand. And it is critical that your policies be well-written and defensible. Confusing, unclear policies are hard to explain, even by an experienced HR witness.
Be Able to Explain Any Departure from Normal Procedure
Jurors will be skeptical when an employer does not follow its usual disciplinary process. Even when a progressive discipline policy allows certain steps to be skipped, the jury will expect a clear explanation for why the company chose to do so. HR should understand the reason for any departure from the normal process and be prepared to address it directly rather than minimize it.
Whether the issue involves skipped disciplinary steps, an accelerated termination, different treatment from other employees, or an investigation that did not follow the usual procedure, the witness should be able to explain why the company’s decision was still reasonable under the circumstances.
Know the Reason for the Employment Decision
Jurors focus heavily on one central question: Why did the employer really make the decision at issue? HR should be prepared to answer that question with a clear and consistent explanation of the legitimate business reason behind the action.
Vague explanations, particularly ones that appear to have been developed only after litigation began, can undermine credibility. HR should know who made the decision, what information was available at the time, and how those facts led to the action taken.
Master the Timeline and Important Documents
Employment cases often develop over months of emails, warnings, complaints, leave requests, evaluations, and meetings, so HR should understand the chronology well enough to explain it clearly and without confusion.
Preparation should include reviewing the documents most likely to appear at trial, such as personnel records, performance evaluations, disciplinary documents, relevant policies, investigation materials, emails, termination records, and prior deposition testimony. HR should know what each important document is, how it fits into the timeline, and why it mattered to the company’s decision-making.
At the same time, the witness should not pretend to remember details that they genuinely do not recall. Most importantly, HR should never see a significant document for the first time on cross-examination.
Get Ready to Explain the Entire Investigation
If HR investigated an employee complaint, such as one for discrimination or harassment, HR should be prepared to explain how the investigation unfolded from beginning to end.
That includes how the matter came to HR’s attention, the steps that were taken, why certain witnesses were interviewed, and what information was considered in reaching a conclusion.
If credibility determinations played a role, HR should also be ready to explain how those judgments were made.
Just as important, if a particular issue was not investigated, the witness should anticipate being asked why. It is not enough to simply say that HR conducted an investigation; HR should be able to explain the process in a way that shows it was thoughtful, reasonable, and grounded in the information available at the time.
Address Bad Facts Instead of Avoiding Them
Every employment case may include a document, statement, mistake, or policy deviation that is difficult for the employer to explain. HR should be familiar with those facts before trial and prepared to address them directly.
When misconduct or an obvious mistake occurred, trying to deny or minimize it can damage the witness’s credibility. It is better to acknowledge what happened, explain its significance accurately, and help the jury understand how it relates to the issues that matter to liability. A bad fact does not necessarily decide the case, but an evasive answer can make it much worse.
Remember that Jurors Are Evaluating Fairness
Jurors may understand the legal instructions they are given, but they will often evaluate the employer’s conduct through their own sense of workplace fairness. They may consider whether the employer’s expectations were reasonable, whether the employee knew there was a problem, and whether the employee had a meaningful opportunity to improve.
HR should therefore be prepared to explain not only what decision was made, but why the process leading to that decision was fair under the circumstances.
Thoroughly Prepare
HR does not need to have an answer for every event or detail that comes up during trial, nor should the witness try to speak beyond the scope of their knowledge. But when an issue falls within HR’s role, HR should be prepared to explain it with confidence and clarity.
Thorough preparation allows the HR witness to provide the jury with a clear picture of how and why the company acted, while avoiding speculation or unnecessary explanations on matters outside their knowledge. Such preparation is time-consuming, emotionally draining, and sometimes costly. But it is time well spent.
C.B. Burns is an attorney with Kemp Smith in El Paso, Texas. Burns is a speaker at LEAP Employment Law Conference, In Partnership With SHRM. LEAP 2027 will be held from March 31 to April 2, 2027, in Las Vegas.
Was this resource helpful?