Skip to main content

Your membership is almost expired! Renew today for unlimited access to member content.

Renew now opens in a new tab

Your membership has expired. Renew today for unlimited access to member content.

Renew Now opens in a new tab

Your Executive Network membership is nearing its expiration. Renew now to maintain access.

Renew Now opens in a new tab

Your membership has expired. Renew your Executive Network benefits today.

Renew Now opens in a new tab
  • Personal
  • Business
  • Foundation
    Close
  • Global
    • Global
    • India
    • MENA
  • mySHRM Login
  • MySHRM
    • Dashboard
    • Accountopens in a new tab
    • Logout
SHRM
  • Membership
    • Membership

      As a SHRM Member®, you’ll pave the path of your success with invaluable resources, world-class educational opportunities and premier events.

      Membership Tiers
      • Professional
      • Student
      • Global
      • Executive opens in a new tab
      • Enterprise opens in a new tab
      Membership Benefits opens in a new tab
  • Certification
    • SHRM Certification

      Demonstrate your ability to apply HR principles to real-life situations.

      • How to Get Certified
      • Eligibility Criteria
      • Exam Fees & Options
      • SHRM-CP
      • SHRM-SCP
      • Which Certification is Best for Me?
      • Recertification
      Prepare for the Exam
      • Exam Preparation
      • SHRM BASK
      • SHRM Learning System
      • Instructor-Led Learning
      • Self-Study
      Specialty Credentials

      Demonstrate targeted competence and enhance your HR credibility.

      Qualifications

      Gain a deeper understanding and develop critical skills.

      Seminars

      Stand out from among your HR peers with the skills obtained from a SHRM Seminar.

  • Events & Education
    • Events

      Demonstrate your ability to apply HR principles to real-life situations.

      • SHRM26 Annual Conference opens in a new tab
      • BLUEPRINT 2025 opens in a new tab
      • Talent Conference & Expo
      • Linkage Institute opens in a new tab
      • The AI+HI Project 2026 opens in a new tab
      • See More
      State Conferences

      Attend a SHRM state event to network with other HR professionals and learn more about the future of work.

      Seminars

      Stand out from among your HR peers with the skills obtained from a SHRM Seminar.

      Webinars
  • Resources
    • Resources

      Stay up to date with news and leverage our vast library of resources.

      • Flagships
      • HR Research
      • Legal & Compliance
      • Latest News & Trends
      • Tools & Guides
      • Webinars
      HR Topics
      • AI in the Workplace
      • Civility at Work
      • Compensation & Benefits
      • Inclusion & Diversity
      • Talent Acquisition
      • Workplace Technology
      • Workplace Violence Prevention
      Educational Programs

      Designed and delivered by HR experts to empower you with the knowledge and tools you need to drive lasting change in the workplace.

  • Community
    • Find a SHRM Chapter

      Easily find a local professional or student chapter in your area.

      SHRM Connect opens in a new tab

      Post polls, get crowdsourced answers to your questions and network with other HR professionals online.

      Membership Councils

      Learn about SHRM's five regional councils and the Membership Advisory Council (MAC).

      Volunteers

      Learn about volunteer opportunities with SHRM.

  • Shop
    • SHRM Store

      Shop for HR certifications, credentials, learning, events, merchandise and more.

      Workplace Essentials opens in a new tab
      Learning
      Merchandise
Become a Member opens in a new tab
Renew
Rejoin Now
Renew
Close
  • Personal
  • Business
  • Foundation
  • Membership
    back
    Membership
    • Membership

      As a SHRM Member®, you’ll pave the path of your success with invaluable resources, world-class educational opportunities and premier events.

      Membership Tiers
      • Professional
      • Student
      • Global
      • Executive opens in a new tab
      • Enterprise opens in a new tab
      Membership Benefits opens in a new tab
  • Certification
    back
    Certification
    • SHRM Certification

      Demonstrate your ability to apply HR principles to real-life situations.

      • How to Get Certified
      • Eligibility Criteria
      • Exam Fees & Options
      • SHRM-CP
      • SHRM-SCP
      • Which Certification is Best for Me?
      • Recertification
      Prepare for the Exam
      • Exam Preparation
      • SHRM BASK
      • SHRM Learning System
      • Instructor-Led Learning
      • Self-Study
      Specialty Credentials

      Demonstrate targeted competence and enhance your HR credibility.

      Qualifications

      Gain a deeper understanding and develop critical skills.

      Seminars

      Stand out from among your HR peers with the skills obtained from a SHRM Seminar.

  • Events & Education
    back
    Events & Education
    • Events

      Demonstrate your ability to apply HR principles to real-life situations.

      • SHRM26 Annual Conference opens in a new tab
      • BLUEPRINT 2025 opens in a new tab
      • Talent Conference & Expo
      • Linkage Institute opens in a new tab
      • The AI+HI Project 2026 opens in a new tab
      • See More
      State Conferences

      Attend a SHRM state event to network with other HR professionals and learn more about the future of work.

      Seminars

      Stand out from among your HR peers with the skills obtained from a SHRM Seminar.

      Webinars
  • Resources
    back
    Resources
    • Resources

      Stay up to date with news and leverage our vast library of resources.

      • Flagships
      • HR Research
      • Legal & Compliance
      • Latest News & Trends
      • Tools & Guides
      • Webinars
      HR Topics
      • AI in the Workplace
      • Civility at Work
      • Compensation & Benefits
      • Inclusion & Diversity
      • Talent Acquisition
      • Workplace Technology
      • Workplace Violence Prevention
      Educational Programs

      Designed and delivered by HR experts to empower you with the knowledge and tools you need to drive lasting change in the workplace.

  • Community
    back
    Community
    • Find a SHRM Chapter

      Easily find a local professional or student chapter in your area.

      SHRM Connect opens in a new tab

      Post polls, get crowdsourced answers to your questions and network with other HR professionals online.

      Membership Councils

      Learn about SHRM's five regional councils and the Membership Advisory Council (MAC).

      Volunteers

      Learn about volunteer opportunities with SHRM.

  • Shop
    back
    Shop
    • SHRM Store

      Shop for HR certifications, credentials, learning, events, merchandise and more.

      Workplace Essentials opens in a new tab
      Learning
      Merchandise
Become a Member opens in a new tab
Renew
Rejoin Now
Renew
    • Global
    • India
    • MENA
SHRM
mySHRM Login
  • MySHRM
    • Dashboard
    • Account opens in a new tab
    • Logout
Close
Already have an account?

  1. Topics & Tools
  2. Employment Law & Compliance
  3. Retaliation Claim Proceeds Based on Manager’s Text Messages
Share
  • opens in a new tab Linked In
  • opens in a new tab Facebook
  • opens in a new tab Twitter
  • opens in a new tab Email

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Vivamus convallis sem tellus, vitae egestas felis vestibule ut.


Error message details.

Copy button
Reuse Permissions

Request permission to republish or redistribute SHRM content and materials.


Learn More opens in a new tab
Court Reportopens in a new tab

Retaliation Claim Proceeds Based on Manager’s Text Messages

March 5, 2024 | Jeffrey Rhodes

Takeaway: Employers can potentially worsen their situations by reacting negatively to an employee’s discrimination complaint.

The 8th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals upheld dismissal of an employee’s age discrimination claim but revived her retaliation claim based on a manager’s texts seeking to limit the plaintiff’s employment options after she claimed age discrimination.

The employee worked for Catalent CTS (Kansas City) LLC from 2012 to 2020, when she was between the ages of 56 and 64. Throughout her employment, the plaintiff received multiple promotions until she was promoted to director/project manager in October 2018.

The year after the plaintiff assumed her role as a director, however, three employees left her team, citing concerns with management and workload. Two of these employees specifically cited the plaintiff as a reason for their departures. In the plaintiff’s 2019 year-end review, Catalent rated her performance as “partially met expectations,” the second-lowest rating on a five-point scale.

In January 2020, Catalent’s Kansas City general manager and the plaintiff’s onsite supervisor left the company. After the general manager left Catalent, members within Catalent’s management and human resources teams discussed the plaintiff’s declining performance.

By February 2020, two more employees from the plaintiff’s team resigned, again citing her as one of the reasons for their departures. Catalent’s management and HR considered three options: 1) place the plaintiff on a performance improvement plan (PIP), 2) demote her to a lower-level position, or 3) end her employment and offer her a severance plan.

Catalent’s management and HR teams were concerned about the risk of the plaintiff running her department while on a PIP.

On Feb. 13, Catalent gave the plaintiff her midyear performance review, told her she was rated “not on track,” and asked her whether she was interested in staying in her current position, but on a PIP, or receiving a demotion to a senior manager role.

Five days later, on Feb. 18, the plaintiff emailed Catalent, writing that she believed her age was a factor in her employment options. In that same email, the plaintiff chose to be placed on a PIP and stay in her position.

Just two days later, on Feb. 20, Catalent met with the plaintiff. She was told that the PIP was no longer an option and she could accept either a demotion or a severance plan. The plaintiff replied that she did not want a demotion. Catalent then provided the plaintiff with the proposed separation agreement, giving her 21 days to review the document. The plaintiff worked from home for the following week. Catalent pressed her to either return to work with a demotion or accept the severance plan. She did not return and was considered to have resigned.

The plaintiff then sued Catalent in Missouri state court, alleging age discrimination, sex discrimination, and retaliation and violation of the Missouri Human Rights Act (MHRA). Catalent removed the case to federal court and filed a motion for summary judgment on all the plaintiff’s claims.

The plaintiff opposed Catalent’s motion regarding her age discrimination and retaliation claims. During the briefing process, Catalent produced court-ordered evidence of certain text messages between members of its leadership.

These texts included a set of messages showing that, one day after the plaintiff claimed age discrimination, the HR manager proposed the idea of removing the option of a PIP and forcing the plaintiff to choose between demotion and termination. The plaintiff’s supervisor asked the global director of project management to approve the idea, and she texted a thumbs-up emoji.

The plaintiff requested leave to use these texts to oppose summary judgment, but the district court denied her request and granted summary judgment against her claims. The plaintiff appealed to the 8th Circuit.

On appeal, the 8th Circuit considered whether the plaintiff had alleged a sufficient claim of age discrimination to survive summary judgment. The plaintiff argued that a younger manager who also had a high number of subordinate resignations was not disciplined. The court noted, however, that the younger manager was not blamed by her departing employees for poor working conditions in the department, as was the plaintiff. Therefore, it stated that the plaintiff’s evidence did not show age discrimination.

Yet, the court found sufficient evidence of retaliation in the texts produced by Catalent to reverse summary judgment on that claim. The plaintiff’s managers apparently removed the PIP option soon after she claimed age discrimination, providing evidence that their decision was retaliatory.

The 8th Circuit thus reversed the grant of summary judgment on the plaintiff’s retaliation claim.

Lightner v. Catalent CTS (Kansas City) LLC, 8th Cir., No. 22-2452 (Dec. 26, 2023).

Jeffrey Rhodes is an attorney with McInroy, Rigby & Rhodes LLP in Arlington, Va.

ESG, Ethics & Compliance opens in a new tab
Ethics opens in a new tab
HR Function Strategy opens in a new tab
HR Technology opens in a new tab


Artificial Intelligence in the Workplace

​An organization run by AI is not a futuristic concept. Such technology is already a part of many workplaces and will continue to shape the labor market and HR. Here's how employers and employees can successfully manage generative AI and other AI-powered systems.



Related Content

Kelly Dobbs Bunting speaks onstage at SHRM24
(opens in a new tab)
News
Why AI+HI Is Essential to Compliance

HR must always include human intelligence and oversight of AI in decision-making in hiring and firing, a legal expert said at SHRM24. She added that HR can ensure compliance by meeting the strictest AI standards, which will be in Colorado’s upcoming AI law.

(opens in a new tab)
News
A 4-Day Workweek? AI-Fueled Efficiencies Could Make It Happen

The proliferation of artificial intelligence in the workplace, and the ensuing expected increase in productivity and efficiency, could help usher in the four-day workweek, some experts predict.

(opens in a new tab)
News
How One Company Uses Digital Tools to Boost Employee Well-Being

Learn how Marsh McLennan successfully boosts staff well-being with digital tools, improving productivity and work satisfaction for more than 20,000 employees.

HR Daily Newsletter

Stay up to date with the latest HR news, trends, and expert advice each business day.

Success title

Success caption

Manage Subscriptions opens in a new tab
Our Brands

SHRM Foundation Logo
SHRM Executive Network Logo
CEO Circle Logo
SHRM Business Logo
SHRM Linkage Logo
SHRM Labs
Overview

  • About SHRM
  • Careers at SHRM
  • Press Room
  • Contact SHRMopens in a new tab
  • Book a SHRM Executive Speaker
  • Advertise with Us
  • Post a Jobopens in a new tab
Advocacy

  • Workforce Development
  • Workplace Inclusion
  • Workplace Flexibility & Leave
  • Workplace Governance
  • Workplace Health Care
  • Workplace Immigration
  • State Affairs
  • Global Policy
  • Advocacy Team
  • Take Action
  • Generation Cares
  • The Section 127 Coalitionopens in a new tab
Member Resources

  • Ask An Advisor
  • SHRM Newsletters
  • SHRM Flagships
  • Topics & Tools
  • Find an HR Jobopens in a new tab
  • Vendor Directoryopens in a new tab

© 2025 SHRM. All Rights Reserved
SHRM provides content as a service to its readers and members. It does not offer legal advice, and cannot guarantee the accuracy or suitability of its content for a particular purpose. Disclaimer

Follow Us

  • LinkedIn opens in a new tab
  • Facebook opens in a new tab
  • Twitter opens in a new tab
  • Instagram opens in a new tab
  • YouTube opens in a new tab

  1. Privacy Policy

  2. Terms of Use

  3. Accessibility

Join SHRM for Exclusive Access to Member Content

SHRM Members enjoy unlimited access to articles and exclusive member resources.

Already a member?
Free Article 1 of 1
Limit Reached
Not Logged In - SHRM Metered Content

Get unlimited access to articles and member-exclusive resources.

You've reached the limit of 1 free article this month. Join to access unlimited articles and member-only resources.

Already a member?
Free Article
Exclusive Executive-Level Content

This content is for the SHRM Executive Network and Executive Content Subscription members only.

You've reached the limit of 1 free article this month. Join the Executive Network and enjoy unlimited content.

Already a member?
Free Article
Exclusive Executive-Level Content

This content is for the SHRM Executive Network and Executive Content Subscription members only.

You've reached the limit of 1 free article this month. Join and enjoy unlimited access to SHRM Executive Network Content.

Already a member?
Unlock Your Career with SHRM Membership

Please enjoy this free resource! Join SHRM for unlimited access to exclusive articles and tools.

Already a member?