Many U.S. Workers Worry They’ll Be Fired

America’s younger workers are especially concerned

Dana Wilkie By Dana Wilkie September 18, 2019
LIKE SAVE

​Even though the U.S. unemployment rate is at a record low, nearly half the country's workers are worried they'll lose their jobs, according to a new poll.

The main reasons workers worry about being fired are:

  • They fear a recession is on the horizon (34 percent).
  • They hear rumors of layoffs at work (32 percent).
  • Their company recently laid off employees (30 percent).

The Harris Poll surveyed 2,204 U.S. adults, 1,061 of them with jobs, and found that 48 percent of those working have what researchers call "layoff anxiety." The Harris Poll conducted the survey on behalf of CareerArc.

The Most Worried? Younger Workers

Among the findings that economic and workplace experts found surprising: Younger workers reported "layoff anxiety" in higher numbers than older workers—even though they tend to have fewer financial responsibilities, such as mortgages and children, than their older counterparts. Sixty-one percent of people ages 18 to 34 reported having layoff anxiety, compared with 41 percent of those 35 or older.

"While younger adults generally have fewer responsibilities and financial obligations, they also tend to make lower salaries and have little seniority," said Robin Richards, CEO of CareerArc, which provides companies with social recruiting and outplacement services. "Younger employees in entry-level positions have the not-unfounded fear they'll be the first let go in the case of a layoff, as they don't yet have the skills, experience and tenure of their older co-workers."

In addition, many younger workers were children during the Great Recession and saw how it affected the adults in their lives.

"Many young people have witnessed firsthand the financial and psychological effects of layoffs on their parents, their relatives or their friends," said Wayne Cascio, global leadership professor at the University of Colorado at Denver, who has studied the impact of layoffs for decades. 

Corporate Layoffs in the Headlines

Low unemployment doesn't remove the chance of layoffs. Technological advancements, the changing needs of companies and automation have all eliminated the need for some jobs.

"Layoffs happen no matter what the economy is doing, whether times are good or bad," Cascio said. "As business strategies and skill requirements change, layoffs are an ever-present possibility for workers everywhere."

This past summer, Deutsche Bank began laying off 18,000 workers—many of them in New York—as it pulls out of the equities business. Last year, Toys R Us fired 30,000 employees after going out of business, while General Motors announced it would let go of more than 14,000 workers in the U.S. and Canada and shut down five plants. Ikea cut 7,500 jobs, and Verizon said 10,400 employees would leave under a voluntary separation agreement.

Those developments, along with trade tensions and stock market volatility, have economists and financial experts warning that a recession may be on the horizon. And workers who were hurt during the last recession—which ended in June 2009—won't soon forget it.

"The experience of a layoff can be deeply traumatic for the people who go through it," Richards said. "In fact, a U.K. study found that people who are laid off become less trusting and more cynical for at least nine years. For many, the emotional scars seem to last longer. Considering the fact that a sizable portion of the U.S. population has experienced not just one but multiple layoffs, terminations or periods of joblessness, it's in many ways unsurprising that layoff anxiety persists."

Many Ill-Prepared for a Layoff

Nearly half of those polled (47 percent) say they're not financially ready for a layoff.

Many Americans may not be earning enough to build an emergency fund, as real wages have remained stagnant for decades, Richards pointed out. In fact, 39 percent of U.S. adults don't have enough savings to cover a $1,000 emergency.

"Americans [aren't good] at saving in general—for rainy days or for retirement," said Patrick Button, assistant professor of economics at Tulane University and a researcher with the National Bureau of Economic Research Disability Research Center. "I believe a large proportion of people don't have enough saved up to cover a month or two of expenses. I should mention that those that are disadvantaged—like those with less education—are more likely to get laid off, and those groups are less likely to have the financial resources to save for a rainy day."

Indeed, the CareerArc Layoff Anxiety Poll found that 64 percent of Americans with college degrees or higher have never been laid off, compared with 48 percent of Americans with some college education and 47 percent of those with a high school degree or less.

But one's education doesn't seem to make a difference when it comes to layoff anxiety: Virtually the same percentage of workers with a college degree (49 percent), with some college (48 percent) and with a high school degree or less (47 percent) worry about losing their jobs.

Quell Groundless Rumors, Talk Openly of Coming Changes

"Since layoff anxiety is so prevalent in the U.S. workforce, it makes sense for companies to manage and address these worries head-on," the researchers wrote. "Company leaders and HR professionals can take steps to both assuage unnecessary fear among employees and prepare for unexpected changes in the business environment."

They recommended that employers help address layoff anxiety by communicating with employees.

"Much of the fuel behind layoff anxiety comes from the fear of the unknown," the researchers wrote. "Thus, it's helpful to let employees in on company decisions as much as possible—especially during times of mergers and acquisitions, management changes or shifts in business focus."


LIKE SAVE

Job Finder

Find an HR Job Near You
Search Jobs

SPONSOR OFFERS

Find the Right Vendor for Your HR Needs

SHRM’s HR Vendor Directory contains over 10,000 companies

Search & Connect

HR Daily Newsletter

News, trends and analysis, as well as breaking news alerts, to help HR professionals do their jobs better each business day.
temp_image