Get access to the exclusive HR Resources you need to succeed in 2018.
Sign up for free email newsletters and get more SHRM content delivered to your inbox.
Is your employee handbook keeping up with the changing world of work? With SHRM's Employee Handbook Builder get peace of mind that your handbook is up-to-date.
Build competencies, establish credibility and advance your career—while earning PDCs—at SHRM Seminars in 14 cities across the U.S. this fall.
Gain the skills you need to rise to the next level in your career. Jon us at SHRM's Leadership Development Forum, October 2-3 in Boston.
Asking the right questions of yourself and a potential employer can help ensure that you end up in the right place.
Members may download one copy of our sample forms and templates for your personal use within your organization. Please note that all such forms and policies should be reviewed by your legal counsel for compliance with applicable law, and should be modified to suit your organization’s culture, industry, and practices. Neither members nor non-members may reproduce such samples in any other way (e.g., to republish in a book or use for a commercial purpose) without SHRM’s permission. To request permission for specific items, click on the “reuse permissions” button on the page where you find the item.
Sadly, the scenario is all too common: You thought you had finally landed the perfect new job. It was a step up with a great title and good pay and benefits. The commute wasn’t bad, and everyone seemed friendly. But in just a few months, it was clear that the perfect fit was really no fit at all. Maybe your boss was a control freak or your co-workers were slackers. Maybe the work wasn’t what you expected or you didn’t have enough support.
It’s an all-too-familiar occurrence for many in the HR field, but if its happened to you, now is the time to make sure you’ve learned from that experience. The reason: This month is a hot time for job seekers. In fact, March is when the Society for Human Resource Managements online job board gets the vast majority of its traffic from both job seekers and employers.
So, as you look for that new job, how can you avoid becoming a casualty of the bad-fit syndrome? Start by thinking about all the reasons for your last bad fit, develop a better sense for exactly what you want next time and learn enough about your next employer to make sure it doesn’t happen again, career experts say.
Whatever you do, don’t underestimate the importance of a good job fit no matter how enticed you are to overlook it in favor of pay, benefits or some other attractive incentive.
The Importance of Fit
Fit is essential because it allows you to feel good about your job, says Carter Womack, president and chief executive officer of Leadership@itsBest in Columbus, Ohio. People who fit in at their workplace are better able to perform and grow, he says. Ignoring warnings of a bad fit can lead to serious repercussions.
You may find yourself frustrated, leaving your job and possibly end up with a bad reference, he says. A variety of factors can lead to a bad job fit, ranging from holding opposing views on etiquette or ethics (for more on ethics, see the cover story on page 48), to having divergent interests, to possessing conflicting views on the direction of the HR office. Knowing which factors are most important to you is key.
Knowing yourself is the first step toward finding a good job fit, career experts say. Do you want to carve out company strategy in the boardroom? Or lead an all-staff meeting to champion a new employee program? Or, do you prefer a more low-key, back-office job in benefits administration?
What do you want from your career? What are you willing to tolerate from an employer and what aren’t you willing to tolerate?
Every question you can think to ask yourself and later find out about a prospective employer puts you that much closer to being a good fit in a new job.
One of the best questions to ask yourself is whether you like change, says Susan Bateson McKay, senior vice president of HR for Human Genome Sciences (HGS), a biotechnology company in Rockville, Md. Then, find out how much change is expected at the company you are interviewing with.
McKay adds: You have to be honest with yourself about what it is you want to do within HR. What most excites you about your work?
When I joined HGS nine years ago, we were in a high-growth mode. If I didn’t want to lead a function in recruiting, this wouldn’t have been a good fit for me, she says. If an
HR person is considering HGS today, the organization is about moving to commercialization and managing change.
If that’s not what they want to do, this isn’t the place for them.
While knowing what you want is important, it can be equally important to know what you don’t want.
For example, Michelle Roccia, vice president of human resources at Authoria, an HR software developer in Waltham, Mass., found out exactly where she did not want to work when she showed up for a job interview at a different company some years ago. A stickler for punctuality, Roccia arrived 15 minutes early, as is standard practice for her. The company kept her waiting 45 minutes past the scheduled interview time and sent no one out to explain the delay. Roccia excused herself and never looked back.
Prepare, Prepare, Prepare
Once you’ve decided on the factors most important to you, you will need to prepare for the interview. While preparation is important for any job candidate, HR professionals have a higher burden than many: Not only must you know your own needs and desires, you also should get a sense for a potential employers workers, as well as the industry they are working in.
For example, you should seek general employee information. Are there many junior-level people or many approaching retirement? How educated are they, and are they in need of more training? Do many commute long distances? Are they asking for flexible schedules or telecommuting? The answers to these questions might determine the issues you would be working on, if hired.
Besides understanding the workforce, you also should try to get a feel for the company image, or at least what the leadership hopes is its image.
To gather such information, start by reviewing the company’s web site, which can provide clues about the organizations style and culture. Some companies show pictures of employees having fun, McKay says. That gives you a clue about how they want to project themselves and probably is not inconsistent with who they are as a company.
Also, look for objective news articles for information that won’t show up in company materials or on web sites, experts say.
If you are using a recruiter, don’t be shy about asking for that persons insights into the true inner workings of the organization. Greg Hessel, who helps place candidates in his role as global head of the Human Resources Center at Korn/Ferry International in Dallas, says it is part of his job to speak honestly with candidates about what client companies are like.
Asked whether he would be forthcoming about a company’s flaws, Hessel replies, Without question, because a bad match hurts everyone the company, the job candidate and the placement firm. Were trying to create a marriage, and we want to make sure that person is successful, he says.
He also encourages candidates to reach out to anyone in their network who might have knowledge of the company.
Finally, you’ll need to prepare questions to determine if the company’s objectives match your own. You have to interview them as much as they are interviewing you, Roccia says. You want to understand the culture. You also want to understand how employee-centric the company is. What tools do they give their managers to perform their jobs?
(For a list of questions to ask of your potential new employer, see
The Top 25 Questions)
Gleaning Fit Info in the Interview
Two years ago, Roccia was looking for an executive-level HR position where she could be involved in company strategy. After researching Authoria and speaking to everyone she knew who was familiar with the company, she applied for the position and was called in for interviews. The first two people she met with were the chief financial officer and the CEO.
That gave me a good impression that HR was very important, Roccia says. I asked them, What is your view of HR? What is HR’s role in the organization? That’s general, but it gave them the opportunity to be specific.
Roccia was careful to listen for a red flag response, such as We consult with HR on an as-needed basis. Instead, the executive’s answers were exactly what she was looking for: that HR is critical to the strategic direction of Authoria.
Liz Bligan, vice president of HR at Primavera, a project management software developer in Philadelphia, also was looking to head an HR office as part of the strategic executive team when she interviewed for her current position. You have to ask, What is HR’s primary role here? If you really want to be a strategic partner and all they’re talking about is how HR keeps us legal and writes good policies and does good business administration, that’s a bad sign. If you’re a mid-level specialist, that may be OK, Bligan says. But if I’m an executive, I want to hear that the VP of HR reports to the CEO or possibly the [chief operating officer].
Besides finding out who the head of HR reports to, McKay suggests finding out if that position is assigned to an executive committee. If the CEO makes all the decisions herself, reporting to the CEO is OK. But if the CEO has an executive committee and you’re not sitting there, you’re not going to have senior-level input.
There also are nonverbal clues about how you might fit in.
Start by using the obvious, says Kathy Basnight, an HR specialist with Maximus Inc., a government consulting company based in Reston, Va. Be perceptive: Is the office bright and clean or dingy? What is the noise and activity level? How do employees interact with each other? How do managers interact with them? Are employees eating at their desks, or are they going out to lunch together? Do managers eat with employees?
Janice Bryant Howroyd, founder and CEO of ACT-1 Personnel Services in Torrance, Calif., says you may want to think twice about a job opportunity if during your visits to the company you notice any of the following:
No matter the flow of your interview, count on being asked to list your job weaknesses, Basnight says. Prepare by understanding your weaknesses and be ready to put the best spin on them, she says but be honest. If you manage to get hired for a job you are not capable of performing, you are setting yourself up for failure, she says.
Will You Fit with Your Supervisor?
Being a good match with your direct supervisor is one of the most important things to determine, says Mark Cenedella, president and CEO of TheLadders.com, a job hunters web site. Most people spend one-third of their day and nearly half their waking hours at work, mostly near their supervisor, he points out.
You can ask questions to try to determine management style, such as What was your most difficult personnel problem, and how did you handle it? But you also should turn up your perception and not ignore your intuition, Roccia says.
From an HR perspective, I think you know as soon as you sit down, Roccia says. That person should put you at ease right away.
Bligan knew she would be a good fit with her Primavera boss when, during the interview, they discovered that she had attended the sister institution to the CEOs high school, an all-boys school in Philadelphia. That information sparked a dialogue in which the two shared common interests and memories that lightened the interview and led to broader discussions. It also let them know that they liked each other enough to work well together, she said.
When you’re a top person reporting to a CEO, you want a good personality fit, Bligan says. Although Bligans chat went well, she cautions people to use their intuition to tell whether the interviewer is open to a lighter, two-way discussion. If so, then proceed with safe topics such as the schools you attended, things you have in common in your industry or possibly special interests like sports. Be careful to avoid personal or inappropriate topics like family, religion or politics, she says.
Being a good personality match doesn’t mean you have to have the same hobbies or sense of humor as your boss. What you do have to have is mutual respect and an agreement about the goals of the organization and how to get there, McKay says. In my 25 years in HR, I’ve worked for a number of people who were very, very challenging, she adds. But if our goals were aligned, I made it work.
What is less likely to result in a good fit is if you get the sense that you know more than your supervisor. Carl Jefferson, national president of the Atlanta-based National Association of African Americans in Human Resources, recalls an interviewer who did not seem to have a good grasp of the company’s vision or how it made its money. If you perceive that you bring more to the table than your primary interviewer, or if you sense possible clashes between your core values and those of your potential new supervisor, then the job may not be a good fit for you, he says.
Seek Your Comfort Level
Finding a good job fit may feel onerous, but HR professionals should be emboldened by knowing they have an advantage over others. Roccia says members of the profession often have heightened intuition and interpersonal skills, which can serve them well in interview situations. You can assess everything right off the bat, she says.
With some intuitiveness and the skills to know what to look for, most HR professionals should have a sense in the first few minutes if they will be a good fit in an organization, says Roccia, who has worked for Authoria for 18 months. When I walked into Authoria, I just knew it was a happening place, she says. There was a special energy. Her advice to others: Let your gut guide you. Look for your comfort level.
Lisa Daniel is a Northern Virginia-based freelance writer who specializes in careers. Carolyn Brandon is a freelance writer in suburban Maryland and has worked as an HR specialist.
Know the Business, Get the Job
The Top 25 Questions
Here are some of the best questions to ask during a job interview to determine whether you will be a good fit, according to the sources cited in this article:
You have successfully saved this page as a bookmark.
Please confirm that you want to proceed with deleting bookmark.
You have successfully removed bookmark.
Please log in as a SHRM member before saving bookmarks.
Please sign in as a SHRM member before saving bookmarks.
Please purchase a SHRM membership before saving bookmarks.
An error has occurred
Recommended for you
SHRM Annual Conference & Exposition
SHRM’s HR Vendor Directory contains over 10,000 companies