U.S. workers have a reputation for not using all of their employer-paid vacation time. Turns out, they can't even catch a break when they do take that time off, according to a new survey of 2,300 workers.
Among the 1,800 U.S. and 500 Canadian respondents:
- 28 percent are pestered by email while on vacation. But it's not all from the boss; 12 percent said they email vacationing colleagues.
- 25 percent are bombarded by work-related texts while they are vacationing; 10 percent said they text vacationing colleagues.
- 8 percent receive messages via phone calls or social media on vacation; 4 percent said they contact vacationing colleagues via phone calls or social media.
And while 82 percent said they are not asked to check emails while on vacation, 48 percent have trouble switching off. Could it be they're simply cleaning out their inboxes and deleting spam mail?
"Our research did not specifically ask whether individuals were checking emails to clean out their inbox or to actively engage in work," said Roman Peskin, co-founder and CEO of Elvtr, which conducted the survey. Headquartered in Los Angeles, Elvtr is a learning platform for individuals to attend virtual classrooms provided by industry leaders.
"However, the fact that 28 percent of U.S. workers reported being bothered by emails during their vacation suggests that their engagement with emails goes beyond mere inbox management. It's likely that they are not just cleaning their inbox but are also responding to and handling work-related matters" while on vacation, he told SHRM Online.
Why Are They Working?
"Nobody wakes up on their day off and thinks 'I better check my emails' because they can't get enough of their job," Viktor Grekov, business productivity expert and founder of the OKR Software company Oboard, told SHRM Online. "They do so because they fear everything will fall apart if they don't."
In fact, 37 percent of respondents to the Elvtr survey said there was no one to delegate their work to during their vacation. Other reasons workers gave for responding to work-related messages during their so-called "down" time:
- Anxiety: 57 percent feel anxious if they don't check their work emails while away.
- Employer expectations: 35 percent feel an implicit expectation to work, but only 3 percent said they were openly asked to work.
- Control issues: 15 percent said they needed to stay in control of their work/job.
- Fear: 8 percent are afraid of losing their job.
- Mistrust: 3 percent said they were concerned colleagues would take advantage of their absence.
Elvtr's findings are not so surprising, given a Pew Research survey in February of 5,902 U.S. workers who don't unplug when the workday is done.
While not drilling down specifically to vacation time, the survey found that in general, 28 percent of workers answer work emails or other messages outside of their normal hours "often or extremely often." More than one-fourth (27 percent) do so "rarely or never," and 12 percent said they don't receive work messages.
Pew found that among respondents with higher incomes, 39 percent were more likely to respond to after-work messages than those with middle or lower incomes (26 percent and 20 percent, respectively).
Members of Generation Z are slightly less likely to respond to work messages than other generations—41 percent versus 46 percent overall, according to Elvtr. Elvtr's survey found 68 percent of all workers admitted to working during vacations—62 percent some of the time and 6 percent often or always.
However, nearly three-fourths (73 percent) of all workers said they feel guilty about working during their vacation.
Setting an Example
"Sacrificing personal time to maintain job security is a common occurrence during financial crises," Grekov said in a statement about Elvtr's findings. "However, this can have devastating consequences for both employees and employers."
In the short term, workers experience increased stress and health issues and a decrease in productivity if they don't have a chance to recharge, he noted. Long term, it can lead to turnover and employers get a reputation for disrupting their employees' personal time.
Businesses should put comprehensive policies and procedures in place, Grekov advised, to make clear they do not condone work encroaching on employees' time off. His other recommendations:
- Create team policies and strategies that address root causes for working while on vacation.
- Set collective goals that don't overly rely on any one individual, for example, so that "progress doesn't come to a standstill whenever a particular worker steps out of the office," Grekov said.
- Provide tools to help employees work smarter and use their time more effectively.
- Set a good example.
- Offer companywide time off.
Some of the responsibility for not unplugging lies with the employee. More than one-fourth (27 percent) of workers told Elvtr that they love their job so much they don't mind working during vacation. Among reasons individuals do so, Psychology Today reported, is because they over-identify with the company, set high performance standards for themselves, or their self-esteem is wrapped up in their work.
Company- or departmentwide time off could help alleviate a tendency to work during off hours.
"American workers are being pushed to the brink, with many sacrificing their well-deserved vacations and downtime in the name of productivity," Peskin noted. "It's high time we hit the 'pause' button on this relentless race."
Was this resource helpful?
Validate your HR expertise
Earning your SHRM-CP credential makes you a recognized expert and leader in the HR field.
Related Content
Learn how Marsh McLennan successfully boosts staff well-being with digital tools, improving productivity and work satisfaction for more than 20,000 employees.
The proliferation of artificial intelligence in the workplace, and the ensuing expected increase in productivity and efficiency, could help usher in the four-day workweek, some experts predict.
As artificial intelligence technology continues to develop, the demand for workers with the ability to work alongside and manage AI systems will increase. This means that workers who are not able to adapt and learn these new skills will be left behind in the job market.