Employers navigating the Family and Medical Leave Act (FMLA) and the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) are facing heightened scrutiny from regulators. Tracy M. Billows, an attorney at Seyfarth Shaw in Chicago, and Elissa Jessup, a senior specialist in Training and Quality Assurance at SHRM, discussed the importance of compliance during a recent SHRM webinar.
“We have seen both the Department of Labor and the EEOC be much more aggressive on FMLA investigations and ADA charges,” Billows said, noting an increase in EEOC charges and litigation. That heightened enforcement is also evident in how agencies are conducting investigations. “The Department of Labor seems to be getting much more aggressive in their onsite audits and investigations and broad requests for information and really trying to delve into whether an employer is in compliance with the FMLA,” Billows said.
The Growing Complexity of ADA Accommodations
At the same time, employers are grappling with a more complex compliance landscape — particularly when it comes to reasonable accommodations.
“The ADA requires an interactive process and interactive dialogue, individualized case by case assessments,” Billows said. “But those dialogues and case by case assessments are getting trickier.”
One factor driving that complexity is the rise in less visible medical conditions in the workforce. “There are tons of invisible conditions like mental health, autoimmune, even migraines, that can flare up,” Jessup said.
To navigate this, employers must prioritize consistency in how they handle accommodation requests. This means “consistently following a process whereby you engage in an interactive dialogue, an individualized case by case assessment of accommodations, whether they’re reasonable or not,” Billows said. She emphasized that process consistency is critical from a legal standpoint. It will be “your best defense and your best way to leverage meeting that requirement of providing a reasonable accommodation consistent with applicable law.”
FMLA Compliance: Getting the Basics Right
While ADA compliance is evolving, speakers stressed that FMLA fundamentals remain essential — and mistakes can still create risk.
The first step is “making sure the medical certification is clear and specific,” according to Jessup. Employers should also focus on communication and structure. This involves setting expectations with the employee and tracking the leave carefully, Jessup added.
Although some courts have adopted a more lenient approach when it comes to compliance, relying on leniency is not advisable. “There are some courts that have taken the position ‘no harm, no foul,’ meaning you provided the leave, even though maybe you didn’t get all your documentation right,” Billows said. However, she cautioned against depending on that defense.
“As a defense litigator, I can tell you, I do not want to rely on the ‘no harm, no foul’ defense,” she said. Instead, employers should ensure they can demonstrate compliance. “I want to be able to rely on the fact that you took all the proper steps, you informed the employee of what they were supposed to do, you informed the employee of deadlines, you documented and followed up,” Billows said.
The ADA-FMLA Intersection
A key risk area for employers is misunderstanding how FMLA and ADA obligations overlap.
“I think one of the biggest myths for employers is once FMLA ends, the employer's obligation ends too,” Jessup said. “But in reality, that's usually when the ADA conversation begins.”
This means employers must be prepared to transition from leave management into the ADA interactive process, rather than treating the end of FMLA leave as the end of their responsibilities.
Emerging Workplace Trends Driving Accommodation Requests
Workplace changes — particularly since the pandemic — are also shaping accommodation requests.
“We’re seeing a number of different things,” Billows said. “Remote work is a huge one, and it’s for pregnancy, disability, you name it.” She noted that the normalization of remote work has changed employee expectations. “Many people got comfortable working remotely during COVID or they figured out how to do it,” she said. “And in some cases, remote work may still be proper for some individuals, but it doesn't mean it's proper for everyone.”
Flexible scheduling is another growing trend, with an increasing number of organizations offering hybrid schedules.
Manager Training and Communication Risks
As accommodation requests increase, the role of frontline managers becomes even more critical — and riskier.
“When managers are not careful about what they're saying or they slip and say something that might sound like they are averse to someone taking leave,” it creates potential liability for organizations, Billows said.
This makes training essential to ensure managers understand both legal requirements and how to communicate appropriately with employees.
Why Job Descriptions Matter More Than Ever
Both speakers emphasized that clear, accurate job descriptions are foundational to compliance — particularly when evaluating accommodations like remote work.
“Make sure your job descriptions are clear and up-to-date,” Billows said. She stressed that employers must go beyond general statements about job requirements. “They really, truly are critical, especially with this issue related to remote work right now and flexible schedules and things like that.”
To streamline accommodation conversations, employers must identify the essential functions of each position. “People think just saying [that] being in the office is an essential function is enough. No, you need to demonstrate it. You need to be able to show how,” Billows said.
A More Demanding Compliance Environment
As enforcement intensifies and accommodation requests become more complex, HR professionals must take a proactive, process-driven approach. Consistency, documentation, and well-trained managers will be essential to navigating the evolving ADA and FMLA landscape — and to reducing legal risk in an increasingly demanding compliance environment.
Was this resource helpful?