For HR leaders, failure can feel particularly consequential. Occupying the front lines of organizational change, implementing new initiatives, or making difficult workforce decisions can create overwhelming pressure to get things right. But what if failure is one of the most valuable tools for becoming a better leader?
Using failure as a springboard was the central message from John C. Maxwell, world-renowned leadership expert, bestselling author, and founder of Maxwell Leadership, during his session at the SHRM Linkage Leadership Institute. In a conversation moderated by Johnny C. Taylor, Jr., SHRM-SCP, president and CEO of SHRM, Maxwell challenged the belief that successful leaders rarely make mistakes.
For him, success and failure are connected. Recognizing that relationship can change how leaders approach challenges. “Mindset is so important. ... How I view things is how I do things,” Maxwell said. “Our perspective is the world that we live in.”
He shared three lessons that leaders can apply to their leadership development and workplace cultures.
1. Recognize That You Can't Achieve Uphill Hopes with Downhill Habits
“Everything worth having is uphill," Maxwell explained. Leaders can’t expect to coast to a goal or achievement without friction. Reaching these new heights demands consistency, discipline, and a willingness to do difficult work.
Maxwell emphasized that whether you’re developing stronger teams, improving workplace culture, or leading organizational transformation, success requires intentional effort. "You can't build uphill with downhill habits," he said.
Maxwell also encouraged leaders to keep success and failure closely connected. When leaders experience success, remembering their failures helps maintain humility and keeps them open to learning. Conversely, during setbacks, remembering past successes provides resilience.
Maxwell reinforces this concept through monthly meetings with colleagues that he calls "learning lunches," where he invites people he considers to be smarter than himself to share the most important life lessons they’ve learned. According to Maxwell, their answers consistently connect meaningful lessons to challenges or adversity.
Leaders can build sustainable organizational success by developing discipline and resilience to push through difficulty and discomfort.
2. Embrace Hard Things and Practice Your Response to Failure
Failure is inevitable, but how leaders respond determines whether the experience becomes a setback or an opportunity for growth.
Maxwell encouraged attendees to understand the difference between a "good miss" and a "bad miss."
A good miss occurs when someone experiences failure, evaluates what went wrong, and makes adjustments. A bad miss happens when someone makes excuses rather than taking accountability.
"The worst excuse you have is the best excuse you have, because you believe in it," Maxwell said. Leaders have to step out from behind their excuses to take accountability. In the process, they demonstrate to employees their ability to reflect and own mistakes as well as how to move forward from them.
Taylor pointed to the challenge of embracing failure, especially when it doesn’t come naturally. "Your framework is that failure is a teacher, and that's not intuitive. The fact of the matter is that none of us want to fail. But you say it's a teacher, not a judge," Taylor said.
He then asked Maxwell how leaders should handle an epic failure, particularly one that occurs publicly.
Maxwell's response was direct: Get over yourself. "Laugh at yourself — everyone else is," he said.
Leaders should take their responsibilities seriously, but Maxwell emphasized that embarrassment or personal pride shouldn't prevent them from moving forward.
3. Ask Yourself: What Would I Do if I Knew Failure Would Make Me Better?
As part of reconsidering how they viewed failure, Maxwell asked attendees to consider a question previously posed by a mentor of his: What would you do if failure wasn't possible?
That question encourages bold thinking, but Maxwell suggested a more powerful alternative: "What would you do if you knew you did fail, and you learned from it and became a better person and leader?"
This perspective changes the relationship between risk and reward. Instead of viewing failure as something to avoid, leaders can recognize it as an essential part of professional development.
"Great is a combination of a lot of good," Maxwell said. He reinforced that meaningful success is built through continued effort and learning.
He also challenged the tendency to regret past failures. Erasing a difficult experience would mean erasing the lessons gained. Rather than focusing exclusively on outcomes, organizations can recognize growth through experimentation, reflection, and adjustment.
Ultimately, Maxwell's message was clear: Failure and success aren't opposing forces. They are connected parts of leadership. Achieving a return on failure means creating workplaces where accountability and learning coexist and challenges are embraced. At the end of the day, setbacks build stronger leaders.
Was this resource helpful?