Effective interviewing enables HR leaders to select candidates whose skills, experiences, and values align with the organization’s strategic objectives. Attracting and retaining the best talent requires more than just filling open seats; it demands a consistent, cohesive hiring strategy. When people, platforms, and purpose are aligned, the result is not just a successful hire, but a stronger, more profitable organization.
This toolkit guides you through some of the decisions you’ll need to make when strategizing your organization’s interviewing style and process. It also offers practical templates and tools for streamlining interviews across teams.
In this episode of the Honest HR podcast, learn ways to make job descriptions and your organization’s digital presence stand out to quality applicants. Plus, get tips for creating a positive experience for prospective employees while gathering the insights you need to make the right hiring decision.
Interviewing should be a lever for organizational success rather than merely a procedural task. HR leaders and managers must look for hires who align with the company’s long-term vision, values, and evolving competency needs. A well-designed interview framework can drive better talent outcomes and strengthen your employer brand in a competitive talent market. To build a future-ready interview process, consider these areas:
Learn as much as you can about every area of your organization. All departments involved in hiring new talent need to be on the same page.
Selecting the appropriate interview type is essential for gathering relevant information and assessing candidates effectively. Different interviewing methods offer distinct advantages, depending on the role, organizational needs, and available resources. This section outlines the main types of interviewing approaches, enabling organizations to choose the best fit for their hiring objectives.
Structured, behavioral, and technical interviews are highly effective when conducted via video conferencing or in person, as these formats facilitate clear communication and standardized assessment. Unstructured interviews and panel interviews typically work best in person or one on one, allowing for deeper rapport-building and nuanced evaluation of candidate responses.
Standardized questions and scoring systems deliver consistency and reduce bias across candidates. Recruiters can harness the power of AI to design interview questions that are thoughtful, inclusive, and aligned with both the role and the candidate.
This approach allows for open-ended conversation, providing flexibility to explore unique candidate experiences and insights.
Organizations can gather multiple viewpoints simultaneously, enhancing the reliability and objectivity of candidate evaluations. These interviews also streamline the hiring process by allowing key stakeholders to assess cultural fit and technical skills together, reducing the need for multiple rounds of interviews.
Focus is placed on past experiences to predict future performance by asking candidates to describe how they handled specific situations.
Specialized skills and problem-solving abilities are assessed through practical exercises or case studies relevant to the role.
For virtual interviews, a one-on-one setting might help candidates focus and build a relationship with their interviewer.
Remote interviews have emerged as a standard practice in professional services recruitment. While they offer notable advantages, there are also challenges that firms must proactively address to ensure effective hiring decisions.
As virtual interviews have become common, a number of bait-and-switch situations are happening. Here are ways to mitigate risk:
Protecting against AI-generated fraud begins with awareness. Educate your employees about the existence and potential dangers of deepfakes in video interviewing.
Making Smarter Hiring Decisions that Support the Business
In this episode of SHRM’s People + Strategy podcast, Susan Schmitt Winchester, former CHRO and author of Healing at Work, discusses how HR leaders can assess skills, complexity capacity, temperament, and role requirements to make better talent decisions and reduce costly mismatches.
Thorough preparation sets the stage for a productive and insightful interview process. Defining what success looks like in a role is a critical step in aligning hiring decisions with your business goals. Take these key steps before meeting with candidates:
WEBINAR
Learn how to leverage AI, build compelling employer brands, and optimize candidate experiences.
Precise AI prompts can help you prepare thoughtful interview questions that align with the competencies required for a role.
Executing the interview professionally and efficiently is critical for obtaining meaningful insights and creating a positive candidate experience. Here are ways to foster open communication and produce a fair evaluation.
Give candidates your undivided attention, put them at ease and be transparent about the process.
Validate your expertise as a strategic talent acquisition partner. This credential addresses the specialized and rapidly evolving field of talent acquisition and is designed to develop your skills in creating a sustainable, high-performing workforce.
Follow-up interviews are typically conducted by hiring managers, team leads, or subject matter experts who will work directly with the candidate or oversee their performance. At this stage, HR may still be involved, but their role often shifts to facilitating the process and coordinating logistics, while the focus of the interview moves toward evaluating technical skills, team fit, and alignment with business needs.
Handling candidate rejections with professionalism and empathy preserves the organization’s reputation and fosters positive relationships. Here are best practices for delivering feedback and maintaining respectful communication with those not selected.
Runner-up candidates could be excellent candidates for future roles. Make them feel valued by showing personalization at the rejection stage and while nurturing them afterward.
An HR leader in a large talent acquisition function would use a variety of metrics to assess the effectiveness of interviews. These metrics ensure that interviews are not only efficient but also predictive of future performance and aligned with organizational goals. Here’s a comprehensive breakdown:
Start with a simple dashboard tracking 3–5 core metrics. Expand as your data maturity grows.
Adhering to legal requirements throughout the interview process is essential to mitigate risk and uphold ethical standards. Consider these critical legal aspects.
SHRM provides HR leaders with expert guidance and frameworks to address interviewing strategy. These webinars are valuable tools for HR pros and other leaders within organizations.
WEBINAR
Discover clear action items to spot, stop, and prevent fraud in your hiring process.
Webinar
Craft a hiring strategy that aligns with your organization’s goals and drives long-term success.
WEBINAR
Boost profitability through improved decision-making and market relevance.