HR professionals can save their organizations a lot of time and money by ensuring that everyone throughout their organizations can give the “gift” of effective feedback, according to Ama Agyapong, CEO of Inclusion Enterprises and a former executive at Target.
Agyapong reduced turnover from 110% to 60% at a Fortune 50 retailer “by implementing a feedback-focused workplace culture,” she said at SHRM26 in Orlando.
Feedback was the top performance management priority listed by talent management executives in SHRM’s 2025 Talent Management Executives: Priorities and Perspectives research report. Executives who listed feedback among their top priorities put enhancing manager-to-employee feedback at the top of their to-do list.
Agyapong advocated for using her “GIFT” framework in conjunction with artificial intelligence tools to have better feedback conversations.
A GIFT That Gives
GIFT stands for 1) Gain permission, 2) Identify facts, 3) Frame the impact, and 4) Trigger collaboration. These four parameters can help managers, HR professionals, or anyone else sketch out a cohesive, productive feedback conversation, Agyapong said.
She created the framework with neuroscience and cultural considerations in mind so that it can work in a range of situations.
“Most people don't like to give feedback, and it's because they've never been taught how — and having a framework helps,” Agyapong said. “I created a framework because I needed repetition. I needed to do the same thing every time to find out: Where am I losing people? Where are my gaps? How can I measure success?”
She also said she believes the framework can supersede many cultural differences. The feedback provider can adjust their conversation to account for someone whose culture communicates in high- or low-context ways or places greater value on the individual or the collective.
Here is how Agyapong’s GIFT method breaks down:
Gain permission: Start by asking whether the recipient of the feedback has time to discuss an issue. If not, schedule the discussion soon. Getting buy-in for the conversation helps ensure engagement and deactivate the brain’s threat response. When you do that before you begin, "it allows someone to actually hear what you're saying,” Agyapong said.
Example: “Do you have a few minutes to discuss your termination recommendation for James? If not, can we put something on the calendar in the next 48 hours?”
Identify the facts: Focusing on observable information grounds the conversation in reality rather than emotion. It helps the feedback recipient “keep their rational brain online and hear the facts without judgment,” which can reduce their urge to get defensive, Agyapong said. It also requires the feedback provider to do their homework and come up with facts gathered from internal reports or specific observed occurrences.
Example: “I reviewed the file and noticed there was only one documented coaching conversation on record.”
Frame the impact: Highlighting the impact that the situation has on other employees, the team, or the business activates an empathy response. "When you activate empathy in the listener, they start to feel the consequence of their actions rather than defending against the accusation,” Agyapong said. If the collective impact isn’t resonating, this step can also include reminding the recipient of the impact on themselves.
Examples: “Without clear documentation, we increase legal risk and make it harder to demonstrate consistency and fairness in our organization.”
“Remember, individual managers can also be held liable for harassment or discrimination, so it’s important for everyone’s sake that we get this right.”
Trigger collaboration: This starts with an open-ended question that helps the feedback recipient actively participate in the solution. Use the answer to get buy-in to move forward with a solution to the issue.
Example: “I know you’re busy, but what additional steps can we take to properly document performance concerns before making a final decision?”
From Uncertainty to Trust: Inclusive Feedback Strategies
In this episode of SHRM’s All Things Work podcast, Ama Agyapong, CEO of Inclusion Enterprises, shared how feedback can foster more trust and collaboration in the workplace.
AI Acts as Coach for Feedback Conversations
AI’s large language models can be extremely helpful in drafting talking points for these conversations. If you provide the GIFT framework as context, you can prompt your AI tool to help you navigate common scenarios or even outline the whole discussion.
Example: This prompt can help HR or a manager prepare for defensiveness in their conversation:
"I need to give feedback to [describe the person], but I expect them to be defensive or dismissive. The behavior is [describe the behavior]. Help me write a GIFT-based conversation that leads with a low-threat permission question, uses neutral and specific language to state the facts, frames the impact in a way that doesn't feel like an attack, and ends with a question that gives them ownership of the solution. Also, give me two to three responses I can use if they push back or shut down."
Example: This prompt can help articulate the impact of a specific behavior:
"I need to give feedback to [describe the person] about [describe the behavior], but I'm having trouble articulating why it matters and how to move forward together. Help me brainstorm the possible impact of this behavior on the team, the work, and the individual's own growth. Then help me write three collaborative, forward-focused questions I can use to invite them into the solution without making them feel blamed or cornered."
Though it may feel silly in the moment, it’s vital to practice these conversations with a human before you have them, Agyapong said.
“I never knew I rolled my eyes when I heard things I didn't want to hear until I role-played with someone,” she said. “You can role-play with [an AI tool], but I strongly suggest you role-play with a person.”
Agyapong said she considers feedback to be her niche within the broader inclusion and diversity space. “I believe that feedback removes barriers and allows talent to be developed, and I also believe that feedback lessens stress and creates trust within the workplace,” she said.
Was this resource helpful?